It is Time to Revisit miRNA Therapeutics
The recent Nobel Prizes awarded to Ambros and Ruvkun have refocused attention on microRNAs (miRNAs). The importance of miRNAs for basic science has always been clear, but the application to therapy has lagged behind. This delay has been made even more apparent by the accelerating pace of successful programs using duplex RNAs and antisense oligonucleotides to target mRNA. Why has progress been slow? A clear understanding of how miRNAs function in mammalian cells is obscured by the fact that miRNAs can exert their effects through multiple complex mechanisms. This gap in our knowledge has complicated progress in drug discovery. Better insights into the mechanism of miRNAs, more rigorous definitions of miRNAs, and more powerful tools for establishing the physical contacts necessary for miRNA action are now available. These advances lead to a central question for nucleic acid therapy-can miRNAs be productive targets for drug discovery and development?
Characterization of the TLR9-Activating Potential of LNA-Modified Antisense Oligonucleotides
Early characterization of the immunostimulatory potential of therapeutic antisense oligonucleotides (ASOs) is crucial. At present, little is known about the toll-like receptor 9 (TLR9)-mediated immunostimulatory potential of third-generation locked nucleic acid (LNA)-modified ASOs. In this study, we have systematically investigated the TLR9-activating potential of LNA-modified oligonucleotides using different mouse and human cell culture systems. Although it has been reported that LNA modifications as well as cytosine methylation of 5'-cytosine-phosphate-guanine-3' (CpG) motifs can reduce TLR9 stimulation by phosphorothioate (PTO)-modified oligonucleotides, we identified CpG-containing LNA gapmers with substantial TLR9-stimulatory activity. We further identified immunostimulatory LNA gapmers without CpG motifs. Unexpectedly, methylation of cytosines only within the CpG motif did not necessarily reduce but could even increase TLR9 activation. In contrast, systematic methylation of all cytosines reduced or even abrogated TLR9 activation in most cases. Context dependently, the introduction of LNA-modifications into the flanks could either increase or decrease TLR9 stimulation. Overall, our results indicate that TLR9-dependent immunostimulatory potential is an individual feature of an oligonucleotide and needs to be investigated on a case-by-case basis.
Antisense Oligonucleotide STK-002 Increases OPA1 in Retina and Improves Mitochondrial Function in Autosomal Dominant Optic Atrophy Cells
Autosomal dominant optic atrophy (ADOA) is an inherited optic neuropathy most frequently associated with mutations. Most variants result in haploinsufficiency, and patient cells express roughly half of the normal levels of OPA1 protein. OPA1 is a mitochondrial GTPase that is essential for normal mitochondrial function. We identified and characterized STK-002, an antisense oligonucleotide (ASO) designed to prevent the incorporation of a naturally occurring alternatively spliced nonproductive exon in . STK-002 dose dependently reduced the inclusion of this exon, and increased OPA1 protein in human cells, including ADOA patient-derived fibroblasts. ADOA patient cells manifest reduced mitochondrial respiration, and treatment with STK-002 improved the parameters of mitochondrial respiratory function in these cells. Since STK-002 increases OPA1 through the wild-type allele, we assessed retinal OPA1 in wild-type cynomolgus monkeys and rabbits after intravitreal administration of STK-002 or a rabbit-specific surrogate. Increased OPA1 protein was produced in retinal tissue in both species at 4 weeks after ASO injection and persisted in monkeys at 8 weeks. STK-002 and enhanced OPA1 immunofluorescence were visualized in retinal ganglion cells of cynomolgus monkeys treated with the ASO. Cumulatively, these data support the progression of STK-002 toward the clinic as the first potential disease-modifying treatment for ADOA.
Levels of Exon-Skipping Are Not Artificially Overestimated Because of the Increased Affinity of Tricyclo-DNA-Modified Antisense Oligonucleotides to the Target Exon
Antisense oligonucleotides (ASO) are very promising drugs for numerous diseases including neuromuscular disorders such as Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD). Several ASO drugs have already been approved by the US Food and Drug Administration for DMD and global efforts are still ongoing to improve further their potency, notably by developing new delivery systems or alternative chemistries. In this context, a recent study investigated the potential of different chemically modified ASO to induce exon-skipping in mouse models of DMD. Importantly, the authors reported a strong discrepancy between exon-skipping and protein restoration levels, which was mainly owing to the high affinity of locked nucleic acid (LNA) modifications to the target RNA, thereby interfering with the amplification of the unskipped product and resulting in artificial overamplification of the exon-skipped product. These findings urged us to verify whether a similar phenomenon could occur with tricyclo-DNA (tcDNA)-ASO that also display high-affinity properties to the target RNA. We thus ran a series of control experiments and demonstrate here that exon-skipping levels are not overestimated owing to an interference of tcDNA-ASO with the unskipped product in contrast to what was observed with LNA-containing ASO.
Peptide Nucleic Acid-Mediated Regulation of CRISPR-Cas9 Specificity
Although CRISPR-Cas9 gene therapies have proven to be a powerful tool across many applications, improvements are necessary to increase the specificity of this technology. Cas9 cutting in off-target sites remains an issue that limits CRISPR's application in human-based therapies. Treatment of autosomal dominant diseases also remains a challenge when mutant alleles differ from the wild-type sequence by only one base pair. Here, we utilize synthetic peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) that bind selected spacer sequences in the guide RNA (gRNA) to increase Cas9 specificity up to 10-fold. We interrogate variations in PNA length, binding position, and degree of homology with the gRNA. Our findings reveal that PNAs bound in the region distal to the protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) site effectively enhance specificity in both on-target/off-target and allele-specific scenarios. In addition, we demonstrate that introducing deliberate mismatches between PNAs bound in the PAM-proximal region of the gRNA can modulate Cas9 activity in an allele-specific manner. These advancements hold promise for addressing current limitations and expanding the therapeutic potential of CRISPR technology.
Near Sequence Homology Does Not Guarantee siRNA Cross-Species Efficacy
Small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) represent a novel class of drugs capable of potent and sustained modulation of genes across various tissues. Preclinical development of siRNAs necessitates assessing efficacy and toxicity in animal models. While identifying therapeutic leads with cross-species activity can expedite development, it may compromise efficacy and be infeasible for certain gene targets. Here, we investigate whether deriving species-active siRNAs from potent human-targeting leads-an approach termed mismatch conversion-can yield potent compounds. We systematically altered potent siRNAs targeting human genes associated with diseases- (ALS), (inflammation), and (HD)-to generate species-matching variants with full complementarity to their target in NHPs, mice, rats, sheep, and dogs. Variants potency and efficacy were measured in corresponding cell lines. We demonstrate that sequence, position, and number of mismatches significantly influence the ability to generate potent species-active compounds via mismatch conversion. Across tested sequences, mismatch conversion strategy ability to identify a species-active lead varied from 0% to 70%. For , lead compounds identified from species-focus screening in mouse and dog cells were more potent than leads obtained from mismatch conversion. Thus, a focused screening of therapeutic lead and model compounds may represent a more reliable strategy for the clinical advancement of siRNAs.
An Evaluation of First-in-Human Studies for RNA Oligonucleotides
Most oligonucleotide therapeutics use Watson-Crick-Franklin base-pairing hybridization to target RNA and mitigate disease-related protein production. Using targets that were previously inaccessible to small molecules and biologics, synthetic nucleotides have provided treatments for severely debilitating and life-threatening diseases. However, these therapeutics possess unique pharmacologies that require specific considerations for their distribution, clearance, and other clinical pharmacology characteristics. Namely, one hurdle in the drug development of these therapeutics remains the prediction of human dose that results in exposures comparable with or below those seen at no observed adverse effect level in animals. For first-in-human (FIH) clinical trials, this often involves allometric scaling based on body surface area (BSA) or body weight (BW). In this study, we reviewed the current literature and surveyed elements across 16 approved oligonucleotide therapeutic New Drug Applications approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration in the period from September 1998 to January 2024, and 89 Investigational New Drug (IND) programs with available FIH clinical trials conducted from January 2015 to January 2024, to understand dose selection in early-stage development of oligonucleotide therapeutics. The surveyed elements across these programs include study design, route of administration, dosing regimen, interspecies scaling approach, and the most sensitive species. Of 89 IND programs and 16 approved therapeutics, intravenous and subcutaneous were the most common route of administration, no observable adverse event levels were frequently derived from nonhuman primates, BSA and BW were adjusted for in similar frequencies, patients were predominantly enrolled in FIH trials, and the most common design was a single or multiple ascending dose trial.
Addressing the Challenges of Treating Patients with Heterozygous Gain of Function Mutations
mRNA Nuclear Clustering Leads to a Difference in Mutant Huntingtin mRNA and Protein Silencing by siRNAs
Huntington's disease (HD) is an autosomal dominant neurodegenerative disease caused by CAG repeat expansion in the first exon of the huntingtin gene (). Oligonucleotide therapeutics, such as short interfering RNA (siRNA), reduce levels of huntingtin mRNA and protein and are considered a viable therapeutic strategy. However, the extent to which they silence huntingtin mRNA in the nucleus is not established. We synthesized siRNA cross-reactive to mouse (wild-type) and human (mutant) in a divalent scaffold and delivered to two mouse models of HD. In both models, divalent siRNA sustained lowering of wild-type , but not mutant mRNA expression in striatum and cortex. Near-complete silencing of both mutant HTT protein and wild-type HTT protein was observed in both models. Subsequent fluorescent hybridization analysis shows that divalent siRNA acts predominantly on cytoplasmic mutant transcripts, leaving clustered mutant transcripts in the nucleus largely intact in treated HD mouse brains. The observed differences between mRNA and protein levels, exaggerated in the case of extended repeats, might apply to other repeat-associated neurological disorders.
A Guide to Chemical Considerations for the Pre-Clinical Development of Oligonucleotides
Oligonucleotide therapeutics, a pioneering category of modern medicinal drugs, are at the forefront of utilizing innate mechanisms to modulate gene expression. With 18 oligonucleotide-based FDA-approved medicines currently available for treating various clinical conditions, this field showcases an innovative potential yet to be fully explored. Factors such as purity, formulation, and endotoxin levels profoundly influence the efficacy and safety of these therapeutics. Therefore, a thorough understanding of the chemical factors essential for producing high-quality oligonucleotides for preclinical studies is crucial in their development for further clinical application. This paper serves as a concise guide to these chemical considerations, aiming to inspire and equip researchers with the necessary knowledge to advance in this exciting and innovative field.
Mass Spectrometry as a Quantitative Tool for SpCas9 sgRNA Quality Control
Mass spectrometry (MS) has long been used for quality control of oligonucleotide therapeutics, including single-guide RNAs (sgRNAs) for clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats techniques. However, the application of MS is limited to qualitative assays in most cases. Here, we showed that electrospray-ionization quadrupole time-of-flight MS (ESI-QTOF-MS) assays can be quantitative for chemical species found in sgRNA samples. More specifically, using a 100-nt SpCas9 sgRNA as the example, we estimated that the limits of quantification for length variants in the range of N - 4 to N + 4 (i.e., 96-104 nucleotides) were equal to or lower than 1%. Our study highlighted the potential of ESI-QTOF in its application as a quality control method for sgRNA molecules.
Phosphorothioates and Me: A Lecture About My 35 Years in Oligo-World on My Receipt of the 2023 Lifetime Achievement Award of the Oligonucleotide Therapeutics Society
Preclinical Pharmacokinetics in Tumors and Normal Tissues of the Antigene PNA Oligonucleotide MYCN-Inhibitor BGA002
Although has been considered an undruggable target, alterations confer poor prognosis in many pediatric and adult cancers. The novel -specific inhibitor BGA002 is an antigene peptide nucleic acid oligonucleotide covalently bound to a nuclear localization signal peptide. In the present study, we characterized the pharmacokinetics (PK) of BGA002 after single and repeated administration to mice using a novel specific enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. BGA002 concentrations in plasma showed linear PK, with dose proportional increase across the tested dose levels and similar exposure between male and female and between intravenous and subcutaneous route of administration. Repeated dosing resulted in no accumulation in plasma. Biodistribution up to 7 days after single subcutaneous administration of [C]-radiolabeled BGA002 showed broad tissues and organ distribution (suggesting a potential capability to reach primary tumor and metastasis in several body sites), with high concentrations in kidney, liver, spleen, lymph nodes, adrenals, and bone marrow. Remarkably, we demonstrated that BGA002 concentrates in tumors after repeated systemic administrations in three mouse models with amplification (neuroblastoma, rhabdomyosarcoma, and small-cell lung cancer), leading to a significant reduction in tumor weight. Taking into account the available safety profile of BGA002, these data support further evaluation of BGA002 in patients with -positive tumors.
Understanding and Rescuing the Splicing Defect Caused by the Frequent Variant c.4253 + 43G>A Underlying Stargardt Disease, by Nuria Suárez-Herrera et al., Nucleic Acid Ther 2024;34(2):73-82; doi: 10.1089/nat.2023.0076
Therapeutic siRNA Loaded to RISC as Single and Double Strands Requires an Appropriate Quantitative Assay for RISC PK Assessment
In recent years, therapeutic siRNA projects are booming in the biotech and pharmaceutical industries. As these drugs act by silencing the target gene expression, a critical step is the binding of antisense strands of siRNA to RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC) and then degrading their target mRNA. However, data that we recently obtained suggest that double-stranded siRNA can also load to RISC. This brings a new understanding of the mechanism of RISC loading which may have a potential impact on how quantification of RISC loaded siRNA should be performed. By combining RNA immune precipitation and probe-based hybridization LC-fluorescence approach, we have developed a novel assay that can accurately quantify the RISC-bound antisense strand, irrespective of which form (double-stranded or single-stranded) is loaded on RISC. In addition, this novel assay can discriminate between the 5'-phosphorylated antisense (5'p-AS) and the nonphosphorylated forms, therefore specifically quantifying the RISC bound 5'p-AS. In comparison, stem-loop qPCR assay does not provide discrimination and accurate quantification when the oligonucleotide analyte exists as a mixture of double and single-stranded forms. Taking together, RISC loading assay with probe-hybridization LC-fluorescence technique would be a more accurate and specific quantitative approach for RISC-associated pharmacokinetic assessment.
Screening Splice-Switching Antisense Oligonucleotides in Pancreas-Cancer Organoids
Aberrant alternative splicing is emerging as a cancer hallmark and a potential therapeutic target. It is the result of dysregulated or mutated splicing factors, or genetic alterations in splicing-regulatory -elements. Targeting individual altered splicing events associated with cancer-cell dependencies is a potential therapeutic strategy, but several technical limitations need to be addressed. Patient-derived organoids are a promising platform to recapitulate key aspects of disease states, and to facilitate drug development for precision medicine. Here, we report an efficient antisense-oligonucleotide (ASO) lipofection method to systematically evaluate and screen individual splicing events as therapeutic targets in pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma organoids. This optimized delivery method allows fast and efficient screening of ASOs, e.g., those that reverse oncogenic alternative splicing. In combination with advances in chemical modifications of oligonucleotides and ASO-delivery strategies, this method has the potential to accelerate the discovery of antitumor ASO drugs that target pathological alternative splicing.
Considerations for Creating the Next Generation of RNA Therapeutics: Oligonucleotide Chemistry and Innate Immune Responses to Nucleic Acids
Splice-Switching Antisense Oligonucleotides Correct Phenylalanine Hydroxylase Exon 11 Skipping Defects and Rescue Enzyme Activity in Phenylketonuria
The gene encodes the hepatic enzyme phenylalanine hydroxylase (PAH), and its deficiency, known as phenylketonuria (PKU), leads to neurotoxic high levels of phenylalanine. exon 11 is weakly defined, and several missense and intronic variants identified in patients affect the splicing process. Recently, we identified a novel intron 11 splicing regulatory element where U1snRNP binds, participating in exon 11 definition. In this work, we describe the implementation of an antisense strategy targeting intron 11 sequences to correct the effect of mis-splicing variants. We used an assay with minigenes and identified splice-switching antisense oligonucleotides (SSOs) that correct the exon skipping defect of variants c.1199+17G>A, c.1199+20G>C, c.1144T>C, and c.1066-3C>T. To examine the functional rescue induced by the SSOs, we generated a hepatoma cell model with variant c.1199+17G>A using CRISPR/Cas9. The edited cell line reproduces the exon 11 skipping pattern observed from minigenes, leading to reduced PAH protein levels and activity. SSO transfection results in an increase in exon 11 inclusion and corrects PAH deficiency. Our results provide proof of concept of the potential therapeutic use of a single SSO for different exonic and intronic splicing variants causing exon 11 skipping in PKU.
Sequence- and Structure-Dependent Cytotoxicity of Phosphorothioate and 2'--Methyl Modified Single-Stranded Oligonucleotides
Single-stranded oligonucleotides (SSOs) are a rapidly expanding class of therapeutics that comprises antisense oligonucleotides, microRNAs, and aptamers, with ten clinically approved molecules. Chemical modifications such as the phosphorothioate backbone and the 2'--methyl ribose can improve the stability and pharmacokinetic properties of therapeutic SSOs, but they can also lead to toxicity and through nonspecific interactions with cellular proteins, gene expression changes, disturbed RNA processing, and changes in nuclear structures and protein distribution. In this study, we screened a mini library of 277 phosphorothioate and 2'--methyl-modified SSOs, with or without mRNA complementarity, for cytotoxic properties in two cancer cell lines. Using circular dichroism, nucleic magnetic resonance, and molecular dynamics simulations, we show that phosphorothioate- and 2'--methyl-modified SSOs that form stable hairpin structures through Watson-Crick base pairing are more likely to be cytotoxic than those that exist in an extended conformation. In addition, moderate and highly cytotoxic SSOs in our dataset have a higher mean purine composition than pyrimidine. Overall, our study demonstrates a structure-cytotoxicity relationship and indicates that the formation of stable hairpins should be a consideration when designing SSOs toward optimal therapeutic profiles.
Multiplexed Screening Using Barcoded Aptamer Technology to Identify Oligonucleotide-Based Targeting Reagents
Recent FDA approvals of mRNA vaccines, short-interfering RNAs, and antisense oligonucleotides highlight the success of oligonucleotides as therapeutics. Aptamers are excellent affinity reagents that can selectively label protein biomarkers, but their clinical application has lagged. When formulating a given aptamer for use, molecular design details can determine biostability and biodistribution; therefore, extensive postselection manipulation is often required for each new design to identify clinically useful reagents harboring improved pharmacokinetic properties. Few methods are available to comprehensively screen such aptamers, especially , constituting a significant bottleneck in the field. In this study, we introduce barcoded aptamer technology (BApT) for multiplexed screening of predefined aptamer formulations and . We demonstrate this technology by simultaneously investigating 20 aptamer formulations, each harboring different molecular designs, for targeting Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer cells and tumors. Screening identified a 45 kDa bispecific formulation as the best cancer cell targeting reagent, whereas screening identified a 30 kDa monomeric formulation as the best tumor-specific targeting reagent. The multiplexed analysis pipeline also identified biodistribution phenotypes shared among formulations with similar molecular architectures. The BApT approach we describe here has the potential for broad application to fields where oligonucleotide-based targeting reagents are desired.
Antisense Oligonucleotide-Based Rescue of Complex Intronic Splicing Defects in
The gene, involved in Stargardt disease, has a high percentage of splice-altering pathogenic variants, some of which cause complex RNA defects. Although antisense oligonucleotides (AONs) have shown promising results in splicing modulation, they have not yet been used to target complex splicing defects. Here, we performed AON-based rescue studies on complex splicing defects. Intron 13 variants c.1938-724A>G, c.1938-621G>A, c.1938-619A>G, and c.1938-514A>G all lead to the inclusion of different pseudo-exons (PEs) with and without an upstream PE (PE1). Intron 44 variant c.6148-84A>T results in multiple PE inclusions and/or exon skipping events. Five novel AONs were designed to target these defects. AON efficacy was assessed by splice assays using midigenes containing the variants of interest. All screened complex splicing defects were effectively rescued by the AONs. Although varying levels of efficacy were observed between AONs targeting the same PEs, for all variants at least one AON restored splicing to levels comparable or better than wildtype. In conclusion, AONs are a promising approach to target complex splicing defects in .