DISABILITY & SOCIETY

America's housing affordability crisis: Perpetuating disparities among people with disability
Burns SP, Mendonca R, Pickens ND and Smith RO
America's housing affordability crisis has had various indirect costs on health and safety among people living with disability. The skyrocketing housing prices have exponentially increased with the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic leaving many people at risk for eviction after federal and local moratoriums providing protection during the pandemic expire. Americans with disabilities have been particularly affected by the affordability crisis and it is expected that this major public health problem will only grow as government-provided protections and supports wane. It is critical that both government and various housing organizations consider ways to support affordability, quality, and accessibility in this particularly hard-hit population.
'Civilising' Deaf people in Tibet and Inner Mongolia: governing linguistic, ethnic and bodily difference in China
Hofer T and Sagli G
The People's Republic of China is home to over 20 million d/Deaf and hard-of-hearing people, many among them belonging to ethnic minorities. Drawing on ethnographic fieldwork in two minority regions, the Tibet Autonomous Region and the Inner Mongolian Autonomous Region, this article comparatively discusses findings on sign language use, education and state welfare policies. The situation in these domains is analysed through the framework of the 'civilising project', coined by Harrell, and its impacts on the d/Deaf and hard-of-hearing among ethnic minorities are shown. For instance, through the promotion of Chinese and Chinese Sign Language over and above the use of local sign and written languages as well as through education and the medicalisation of disabilities.
Choices and rights: eugenics, genetics and disability equality
Shakespeare T
From the case files: reconstructing a history of involuntary sterilisation
Park DC and Radford JP
Experiences of visually impaired students in higher education: Bodily perspectives on inclusive education
Lourens H and Swartz L
Although previous literature sheds light on the experiences of visually impaired students on tertiary grounds, these studies failed to provide an embodied understanding of their lives. In-depth interviews with 15 visually impaired students at one university demonstrated the ways in which they experienced their disability and the built environment in their bodies. At the same time, lost, fearful, shameful and aching bodies revealed prevailing gaps in provision for disabled students. Through this research it becomes clear how the environment is acutely felt within fleshly worlds, while bodies do not fail to tell of disabling societal structures. Based on the bodily stories, we thus make recommendations to improve the lives of visually impaired students on tertiary campuses.
'It's better if someone can see me for who I am': Stories of (In)visibility for Students with a visual impairment within South African Universities
Lourens H and Swartz L
Issues of visibility, invisibility and the nondisabled gaze are very relevant to the lives of many disabled persons. With this paper we tentatively show that, despite the physical 'over'visibility of disabled bodies, many intricate parts of their personhood remain obscured and invisible. Interviews with 23 students with a visual impairment revealed that they sometimes experienced stares and averted gazes from their sighted counterparts. In response, they often hid their entire impairment, or parts thereof, in an effort to conform and gain acceptance and to earn membership to a nondisabled peer group. Acceptance was often found in companionship with fellow disabled peers. Since these stories told of continuing exclusion for disabled students on tertiary grounds, further participatory research is recommended.
'If I was a different ethnicity, would she treat me the same?': Latino parents' experiences obtaining autism services
Angell AM and Solomon O
This article reports on an ethnographic study with 12 Latino families of children on the autism spectrum related to obtaining autism services in Los Angeles County. Using critical discourse analysis of interviews, observations, and records, we consider the experiences of the Latino families in relation to: 1) A discursively constructed 'autism parent' subject position that mandates 'fighting' service systems to 'win' autism services for children, originating from White middle-class parents' socio-economic resources and social capital; 2) A neoliberal social services climate that assumes scarcity of available resources and prioritizes austerity in their authorization; and 3) A media and institutional 'cultural deficit' discourse that attributes disparities in autism services for Latino children to their parents' presumed culturally-based 'passivity.' We argue that parental discourse about fighting, or not fighting, for autism services is engendered by a tension between a parental logic of care, and the logic of competition of the economic market.
Barriers and facilitators to mammography among women with intellectual disabilities: a qualitative approach
Arana-Chicas E, Kioumarsi A, Carroll-Scott A, Massey PM, Klassen AC and Yudell M
Although women with intellectual disabilities have the same breast cancer incidence rate as women without intellectual disabilities, they have fewer mammograms and higher mortality rates. Qualitative inquiry was employed to explore barriers and facilitators to mammography among this population. In-depth qualitative interviews were conducted with 30 women with intellectual disabilities and their caregivers in Philadelphia during 2015-2016. Thematic analysis was conducted using inductive and deductive coding. While results provide further evidence for prior research on barriers to mammography among women with intellectual disabilities (e.g. being unprepared, fear of the exam), this study generated novel barriers such as lack of breast ultrasound awareness, sedation failing to work, and lack of mammogram education in adult day programs, and novel facilitators such as extended family support and positive attitudes. Results support the need to address barriers and promote facilitators to improve the breast cancer screening experience among women with intellectual disabilities.
Can Universal Basic Income work for disabled people? An examination of existing UK organisational and academic positions
Johnson EA, Reed HR and Johnson MT
Universal Basic Income (UBI) has been proposed as a means of addressing a range of issues relating to welfare systems, including by removing disincentives to economic, social and physical activity. However, UK disability organisations and figures have expressed concerns about whether UBI could lead to unintended consequences for people who currently receive support conditional on needs, means and/or behaviour. In this article, we outline prominent positions regarding disabled people in the literature on UBI and welfare reforms. We find that while there are reservations about the intentions and designs of UBI, there are means of securing positive outcomes and collaboration between its supporters and disability organisations. We also attempted a consultation but were unable to obtain a significant response. This was sometimes due to an expressed inability to respond meaningfully. This serves as a call for organisations to engage with UBI as a key issue of interest to disabled people.
A care-ethical exploration of the experiences of young adults with mild intellectual disabilities
van Nistelrooij I and Niemeijer A
Care ethics considers the moral good as arising within practices and in people's experiences in these practices. This contribution applies a care-ethical approach to inquire into the effects of a major change in the social domain policy in The Netherlands. The new policy is based upon the expectation that young adults with Mild Intellectual Disabilities (MID) become 'active citizens, participating in their neighborhood', with the support of care organizations and local municipalities. Accordingly, care responsibilities were transferred to the local level (municipalities). On this level, however, basic insights were lacking concerning the needs and wishes of the young adults with Mild Intellectual Disabilities, and concerning the possibilities for local collaboration. Research was performed by taking Joan Tronto's definition of care as a starting point and applying a method adequate to capture young adults' experiences in one municipality. We conclude that this neighborhood is not an environment wherein they can participate. Points of interestThis article offers new insight into the effects of a major change in long-term care policy in the Netherlands that emphasizes participation.Care ethics focusses on practices, in which more than two people are involved, that help meet needs of care (or fail in this respect).The article presents an inquiry into the experiences and needs of six participants living in a Dutch facility where youths and young adults with Mild Intellectual Disability are supported to participate in society, as expressed by themselves in photos and interviews and as observed through the method of shadowing.The results of this inquiry are three aerial photos that show how the participants live in supporting networks with gaps, underscoring their experiences of being displaced and feeling unacknowledged in the vicinity of their home.Different organizations directed at care for young adults with Mild Intellectual Disability can learn from the care needs that result from this way of organizing care.
Neurodiversity studies: mapping out possibilities of a new critical paradigm
Stenning A and Bertilsdotter-Rosqvist H
Neurodevelopmental classifications and the collective idea of neurodivergence can be seen as a 'moving target'. In our understanding, this means that it responds to the needs of society as well as potentially infinite neurological differences between humans. Therefore, rather than assume that neurodiversity exists according to the existing clinical categories of autism and related conditions (that are often centred around autism as the exemplary kind of neurodivergence), we leave the possibility open that there are other forms of difference that have yet to be defined. In the paper we explore how neurodiversity has been described as a collective property of brains, as we try to negotiate between us what it is to be human and how we can work together to ensure our flourishing and to alleviate suffering. We consider implications of this understanding of neurodiversity for autism research, and propose that we unpick the analogy between neurodiversity and biodiversity.
Burden of support: a counter narrative of service users' experiences with community housing services
Heerings M, van de Bovenkamp H, Cardol M and Bal R
Community housing services adopt care models such as rehabilitation, recovery-oriented care and person-centered planning to improve the quality of life of service users with an intellectual or psychiatric disability. However, the way these care models are implemented and practiced can negatively impact service users' experience with the service as their complex needs go unmet. In this paper, we conceptualize these experiences through developing the counternarrative of burdens of support. For this we draw on burden of treatment theory. We conducted ethnographic fieldwork in a community service organization in the Netherlands. This included participant observation (84 h), interviews with service users ( = 20), experts-by-experience ( = 8), family members ( = 10) and photovoice workshops. Our analysis identifies four burdens of support: burden of self-determination; re-identification; responsibilisation and re-placement. The results show that burden of support is very much a relational concept: through their support, professionals can aggravate or alleviate burden.
Experiences of identifying pre-school children with disabilities in resource limited settings - an account from Malawi, Pakistan and Uganda
Lynch P, Nabwera HM, Babikako HM, Rasheed M, Donald KA, Mbale EW, Stockdale E, Chand P, Van den Heuvel M, Kakooza Mwesige A and Gladstone M
Although access to effective medical care for acutely sick children has improved globally, the number of children surviving but who may not be thriving due to disability, is increasing. This study aimed to understand the views of health professionals, educators and caregivers of pre-school children with disabilities in Malawi, Pakistan and Uganda regarding early identification, referral and support. Using applied thematic analysis, we identified themes relating to; limited 'demand' by caregivers for services; different local beliefs and community perceptions regarding the causes of childhood disability. Themes relating to 'supply' of services included inability to respond to community needs, and inadequate training among professionals for identification and referral. Stepwise, approaches provided to the families, community health worker and higher-level services could include training for community and primary care health workers on basic identification techniques and enhanced awareness for families and communities on the importance of early identification of children with disabilities.
Barriers to cultural participation by people with disabilities in Europe: a study across 28 countries
Leahy A and Ferri D
This article discusses the findings of a new qualitative study conducted in 28 European countries, examining barriers to cultural participation as perceived by representatives of organisations of people with disabilities. The study explores barriers operating in all art-forms as well as in cultural heritage, and it encompasses participation of people with a broad range of disability types both as audiences and as creators of culture. The article evidences that a range of interlinked barriers are commonly perceived by people with disabilities in five areas - lack of effective laws and policies; inadequate services and/or funding; negative attitudes; lack of accessibility; and lack of involvement of persons with disabilities in cultural organisations. The article argues for more systematic approaches to enforcement of laws and policies, for greater knowledge about disability to be embedded within cultural organisations and policymaking, and for employment of people with disabilities at all levels within cultural sectors.
Disability stories: personal perspectives of people with disabilities on navigating the U.S. health system
Colorafi K, Cupples L, Kallman D and Kennedy J
Americans with disabilities and chronic illness or injury tend to be in poorer health, use more health services, and pay more for healthcare than those without disabilities. Consequently, their lives can be profoundly affected by federal and state health policies. The concerns of this population do not figure prominently in national health policy discourse and related public health and health services research efforts. This study sought to give voice to the lived experiences of people with disabilities as they navigate a fragmented U.S. healthcare system. We interviewed 30 adults who self-identified as having a disability and spoke or otherwise communicated in the English language. Directed content analysis was used to examine words and phrases in professionally transcribed documents by experienced qualitative researchers. We report and discuss four themes from the perspective of the participant, presented in thematic statements, related to vocation, finances, stressors, and advocacy.
Disability in an eastern religious context: historical perspectives
Miles M
Disability in the past of eastern religions has attracted little formal or comparative scrutiny. A range is sketched here of historical data, viewpoints and attitudes on disability in Hinduism, Buddhism and Islam, which continue to influence the thoughts of half the world's population. Approaches for more detailed studies are suggested, moving towards such global measures for understanding, remediating and accommodating disability as would be more appropriate and acceptable to the non-western majority. Popular notions associated with disabilities in these religions are discussed.
Participatory curriculum development for health and independent living for disabled people: a qualitative study of participant experiences
Standley K, Sage R, Hargrove T, Willard M, Barrett TB, Ender J and Ravesloot C
Participatory curriculum development is an approach that draws on participatory research philosophy by engaging members of intended audiences in the curriculum development process. This is a fairly new approach to curriculum development, which has seldom been applied in health promotion and, to our knowledge, has not previously been used to develop curriculum with disabled people. In this project, participatory curriculum development was used to both develop a new curriculum and revise an existing curriculum for in-person, web-based delivery. We engaged in this process with Center for Independent Living staff members, twelve of whom we interviewed post-engagement. We assessed the development process for equitable engagement and sharing of power and identified three relevant main themes: learning, collaborating, and empowering. Our project partners engaged collaboratively in project development and believed the curriculums would empower their intended end-users. However, they desired greater sharing of power during the process to create an equitable experience.