NURSING ETHICS

Student reflections on the 2024 nursing ethics conference: 'Ethics, care and the workforce crisis' - At Brunel University of London
Nursing advocacy and activism: A critical analysis of regulatory documents
Mainey L, Richardson S, Essex R and Dillard-Wright J
Advocacy and activism are dynamic terms representing a spectrum of political action, aiming to achieve social or political change. The extent to which nursing advocacy and activism are legitimate nursing roles has been debated for around 50 years. Nursing regulatory documents, such as codes of conduct and professional standards, may provide direction to nurses on how they should act in the context of advocacy and activism. To explore what regulatory documents say about advocacy and activism, either explicitly or implicitly, and how they shape advocacy and activism. We used a Reflexive Qualitative Document Analysis approach with a Critical Feminist lens to analyse contemporary nursing regulatory documents from the USA, UK and Australia. This article has no human participants, and informed consent was not required. We identified eight nursing regulatory documents from the American Nurses Association, Nursing and Midwifery Council and Nursing and Midwifery Board of Australia. We constructed two major themes that reveal how nursing advocacy and activism are conceived and shaped in regulatory documents. Theme 1, describes the gendered and neoliberal subtexts influencing advocacy and activism. Theme 2, , describes the shape of advocacy and activism in the regulatory documents. Regulatory documents from the USA, UK and Australia support diplomatic nursing advocacy and activism for people, equity, ourselves (nurses), the profession and systems change. However, more oppositional and disruptive advocacy and activism are potentially constrained by gendered and neoliberal subtexts that depoliticise nurses' roles.
Triage ethics in mass casualty incident simulation: A phenomenological exploration
Watson AL, Drake J, Anderson M, Heaston S, Schmutz P, Reed C and Rasmussen R
Disaster scenarios challenge both novice and experienced nurses to navigate complex ethical dilemmas in resource-limited environments. Traditional nursing education often leaves new nurses unprepared for the ethical demands of disaster nursing. Utilitarianism must often guide triage ethics and decision-making. There is a critical need to equip nursing students with these ethical competencies.
Associations between self-compassion and moral injury among healthcare workers: A cross-sectional study
Gilbert-Ouimet M, Zahiriharsini A, Lam LY and Truchon M
Healthcare workers (HCWs) can face situations that conflict with their moral beliefs, leading to moral injury, an adverse psychological consequence that was more frequent during the COVID-19 pandemic. Self-compassion is a potential coping mechanism for moral injury by encouraging acceptance of human limitations and suffering.
Legal dissemination protections in community-based participatory health equity research
Boutain DM, Sanon Rosemberg MA, Kim E and Evans-Agnew RA
There are legal protections for nurse researchers at public universities who employ community-based participatory research (CBPR) in research about social or health inequities. Dissemination of CBPR research data by researchers or participants may divulge unjust laws and create an imperative for university involvement.
The ethical dimensions of utilizing Artificial Intelligence in palliative care
Oh O, Demiris G and Ulrich CM
Palliative care aims to improve the quality of life for seriously ill individuals and their caregivers by addressing their holistic care needs through a person- and family-centered approach. While there have been growing efforts to integrate Artificial Intelligence (AI) into palliative care practice and research, it remains unclear whether the use of AI can facilitate the goals of palliative care. In this paper, we present three hypothetical case examples of using AI in the palliative care context, covering machine learning algorithms that predict patient mortality, natural language processing models that detect psychological symptoms, and AI chatbots addressing caregivers' unmet needs. Using these cases, we examine the ethical dimensions of utilizing AI in palliative care by applying five widely accepted moral principles that guide ethical deliberations in AI: beneficence, nonmaleficence, autonomy, justice, and explicability. We address key ethical questions arising from these five core moral principles and analyze the potential impact the use of AI can have on palliative care stakeholders. Applying a critical lens, we assess whether AI can facilitate the primary aim of palliative care to support seriously ill individuals and their families. We conclude by discussing the gaps that need to be further addressed in order to promote ethical and responsible AI usage in palliative care.
Unethical conduct as a multifaceted phenomenon in psychiatric care: Nurse leaders' perspectives
Björklund J and Hemberg J
Mental healthcare can be considered a unique practice due to its ethical characteristics, and an awareness of ethics is crucial when working in a mental health setting. Several ethical challenges exist, and professionals may not always recognize the ethical aspects of psychiatric care. Research on psychiatric care from nurse leaders' perspective is scarce but important, because nurse leaders can impact and cultivate workplace culture. To explore the phenomenon of unethical conduct in a psychiatric inpatient context from nurse leaders' perspectives. Qualitative exploratory design. In-depth semi-structured interviews. Eight nurse leaders from two different healthcare organizations in Finland. Leadership experience ranged between 2 and 30 years. Research ethics permission was received from a Research Ethics Board where the researchers are domiciled. Guidelines on good scientific practice as delineated by the Finnish Advisory Board on Research Integrity TENK were followed. Six main categories were generated: Unethical conduct and violations against patients, Unethical conduct and violations against staff, Unethical conduct and violations by staff against other staff, Unethical conduct and violations against leaders, Reasons underlying unethical conduct, and Consequences of unethical conduct and the positive development of psychiatric care. Unethical conduct was seen to be a multifaceted phenomenon, and patients and staff alike can experience and engage in unethical conduct. Unethical conduct against patients was linked to power imbalance (nature of involuntary care, staff attitudes) and a focus on rules based in historical precedent (paternalistic, routine-focused, not patient-centered). Unethical conduct against staff was linked to the nature of involuntary care and patient ill-health. Unethical conduct by staff against other staff was linked to a lack of understanding for others' work, interpersonal chemistry, (length of) work experience, and staff character. Unethical conduct against leaders was linked to leaders being perceived as the organization.
Ethical climate and turnover intention among nurses: A scoping review
Ammari N and Gantare A
Nursing shortages and turnover pose significant challenges for health organizations worldwide, driven by various organizational and individual factors. Ethical climate has emerged as a critical aspect influencing nurses' well-being and retention within healthcare settings, reflecting organizational practices with moral implications. Understanding the relationship between ethical climate and turnover intention among nurses is paramount for practitioners, managers, and policymakers.
Dignity of women with systemic lupus erythematosus: A qualitative study
Mohebbi Z, Bagherian S, Eckert M and Tehranineshat B
The nature of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and the far-reaching unpleasant consequences of this disease and the treatments can put the dignity of the women with the disease at risk. Yet, the dignity of this population of patients has not been the subject of much research. The present study aims to define and describe the concept of dignity of women with SLE. This is a qualitative descriptive study in which data were collected via individual, in-depth, semi-structured interviews. The collected data were analyzed using methods of content analysis in MAXQDA 2010. In total, 29 individuals (14 patients, 8 family caregivers, and 7 nurses) were selected by purposeful sampling from the internal wards of a teaching hospital located in the south of Iran. The study was conducted between June 2023 and February 2024. Sampling continued until the data were saturated. The Institutional Review Board of the university has verified that the study complies with research ethics. Analysis of the data extracted from the interviews resulted in three themes: respect for identity, compassion in care and treatment, and fulfillment of support needs. The women with SLE who were surveyed in the present study needed to have their feminine identity and social identity respected and be comprehensively supported by their treatment team and family caregivers. In such a context, care characterized by compassion and empathy and treatment teams' respectful and professional interactions with the patients contribute to maintaining the patients' dignity. Nursing managers and staff can use the findings of the present study to create a supportive clinical environment in order to better maintain the dignity of women with SLE.
Ethical aspects of staff responses when older people with dementia express false beliefs
Villar F and Martínez D
Challenging false beliefs are common situations among people living with dementia. They frequently imply time-shifts, that is, situations in which the person re-lives past experiences. Since they have emotional implications and important ethical implications, they are difficult to manage by caregivers, who are faced with the decision of telling or not telling the truth.
Nurses' adherence to ethical principles - A qualitative study
Wong V, Hassan N, Wong YP, Chua SYN, Abdul Rahman S, Mohamad ML and Lim S
Nursing is regulated by a set of professional standards. Whilst many forms of ethics apply to nursing, the biomedical ethical framework is common, involving autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice. In healthcare, nurses often encounter ethical dilemmas that require them to navigate conflicting ethical principles. However, how nurses adhere to these principles in such situations is unclear.
Assessment of ethical sensitivity in nursing students: Tools, trends, and implications
Lyu Y, Liang X, Li J and Chi C
Rapid advances in medical technology, changing healthcare policies, and increasing patient diversity have exacerbated the ethical challenges. As nursing students are an integral part of the future nursing workforce, ethical sensitivity has a critical impact on their future careers.
The invisible wounds of women: Ethical aspects of obstetric violence
Yildirim S and Mert-Karadas M
The quality of care in maternity facilities significantly influences women's autonomy and their right to make decisions about their bodies. Obstetric violence, a form of gender-based violence during childbirth, poses serious threats to women's rights and health worldwide. The research aimed to examine women's experiences and perceptions of obstetric violence using the micro-level constructivist grounded theory strategies of Mena-Tudela et al. (2023). This study used a phenomenological qualitative research design. Data were collected from 17 eligible women using a Participant Information Form and a Semi-Structured Interview Form, applying maximum variation sampling to ensure a wide range of sociodemographic characteristics and diverse views and experiences. The data were analyzed using the seven-step phenomenological analysis method. A total of 17 women who had vaginal labor at least 6 months ago were interviewed. The study was approved by the University Ethics Board for Non-Interventional Clinical Studies. Ethical considerations were closely aligned with the principles of respecting women's rights, ensuring that participants' autonomy and consent were central throughout the research process. Five themes and 13 subthemes were extracted from the data analysis, including "Ignoring women in care," "The commodification of women," "Are the healthcare professionals the only authority?", "Ineffective childbirth management and its effects on women's health-seeking behavior," and "Types of obstetric violence." This study underscores the urgent need to address obstetric violence, recognizing its detrimental impact on women's rights, and well-being during childbirth. Protecting women's rights by prioritizing individual-centered care, informed consent, and respectful treatment is essential to uphold ethical standards and ensure dignified childbirth experiences for all women.
Health advocacy and moral distress among nurses in organ transplant units
Victorino JP, de Brito ES, Westin UM, Vargas MAO, Mendes KDS and Ventura CAA
Health advocacy is crucial for both patients and healthcare professionals. However, nurses who recognize the importance of health advocacy may experience heightened moral distress, particularly in complex donation and transplantation cases where patient autonomy, respect, and advocacy are paramount.
Axiological reflection for nursing ethics education: The missing link in understanding value conflicts
Groothuizen JE
Texts from various areas of the world highlight the importance of moral values like compassion and integrity in healthcare. Such values are held in high esteem by healthcare organisations and are actively 'taught' within nursing ethics education to ensure their presence within the future workforce. With such an emphasis, it is easy to overlook that moral values are not the only values that people, including nurses, hold. personal values - which may or may not conflict with moral values - are simultaneously present within individuals. Therefore, moral behaviour cannot be predicted solely by the presence/absence of certain moral values. Instead, it depends on how these integrate into an individual's broader values system.Using Schwartz's axiological Theory of Basic Human Values as a framework, I argue that moral values are but one part of an individual's greater personal values spectrum, which also includes, for instance, hedonism, achievement, and power. Within this spectrum, values are ordered hierarchically, influencing behaviour based on relative priority. When a conflict arises between moral and other personal values, the prioritisation of moral values is a requirement for moral behaviour.I discuss how socialisation in suboptimal clinical practice environments can cause moral values to be deprioritised and argue that the development of practical reasoning skills is paramount to learning to balance one's values and guide decision-making. I advocate for the integration of (meta-)axiological reflection - characterised by introspection and aimed at developing a deeper understanding of one's personal values spectrum - within nursing ethics education. This involves exploring the origin, meaning, and perceived relative importance of one's different personal values. By incorporating specific reflective exercises, students can increase self-awareness/insight and enhance their ability to recognise situations where conflicts between their moral values and other personal values may occur, which is likely to benefit moral decision-making in clinical practice.
Stimulating ambulance specialist nurse students' ethical reflections by high-fidelity simulation
Wihlborg J, Andersson U, Sterner A, Sandman L, Kängström A and Boysen GN
Ethical competence in professional practice can be considered essential among nurses and nurses in ambulance care encounter ethical dilemmas frequently. To enhance ethical competence among students in the ambulance specialist nursing program, high-fidelity simulation scenarios including ethical dilemmas were introduced as a learning activity. The research aim was to investigate the usefulness of high-fidelity simulation in ambulance specialist nurse education to teach ethical reasoning when caring for children. This study was conducted as a qualitative interview study, complemented with observations and using field notes and qualitative interviews for data collection. Data was analysed using deductive qualitative content analysis based on a care ethical model. Participants ( = 35) were recruited from an ambulance nurse educational program at a Swedish university. Data was collected after the students took part in two high-fidelity simulations involving children in an ambulance care setting. The study has been vetted and approved by the ethical council at the University of Borås, Sweden. The study follows the Helsinki Declaration's advice on ethical principles. The results showed that most of the students expressed some form of ethical reasoning during the simulation sessions, which were elaborated and reflected upon during the debriefing part of the sessions. The simulation design seemed to have a great impact on the outcome of the student's ethical reasoning, where increased immersion led to deeper emotional engagement among the students which increased awareness of their personal preconceptions. This study aimed to investigate whether high-fidelity simulations could be useful to stimulate ethical reflections and contribute to increased ethical competence among students. In conclusion, a well-designed high-fidelity simulation can be useful as an educational tool to learn and enhance ethical competence among specialist ambulance nursing students.
Educational needs of midwifery students in medical ethics: A qualitative study
Bayrami R, Ghasemzadeh N and Montakhabi Oskuii D
Ethics education is a basic part of midwifery education program. However, there is no evidence to show that ethics education has been able to meet the educational needs of midwifery students. This study aimed to explore the educational needs of students for ethics in midwifery program with a focus on the course of history, ethics, and rules of midwifery. The present study is qualitative descriptive content analysis research, exploring midwifery students' needs of ethics education in bachelor's degrees. We conducted in-depth semi-structured interviews with 11 undergraduate midwifery students, seven midwives working in hospitals and health centers, and seven midwifery faculty members in Urmia University of Medical Sciences. The participants were selected using a purposeful sampling method and invited to join the study from December 2021 to June 2022. The sampling continued until data saturation. Content analysis identified four categories and associated subcategories: 1. "The client's rights": respecting the dignity of clients, confidentiality, the client's right to choose and make decisions; 2. "Legal and ethical requirements of fertility": abortion, alternative treatment for infertility, domestic violence; 3. "Communication skills": communication with the client, communication with clients' caregivers and communication with colleagues; and 4. "ethical principles in research": compliance with ethical principles in the research process and ethical principles in publishing research findings. The study was approved by the Ethics Committee of Urmia University of Medical Sciences. Before filling the questionnaires, written informed consent was obtained from the participants. The participants were assured of the confidentiality of personal information. The educational needs of midwifery students can be met by providing theoretical and practical training on respecting the pregnant mother, communication skills, legal and ethical aspects of the reproductive period, and incorporating ethical principles in related courses.
Interventions for the promotion of the ethical environment among health professionals: Scoping review
Carpes Lanes T, de Lima Dalmolin G, Villagran CA, Azevedo Wagner Benetti S and Ramos FRS
Education is a tool for the promotion of ethical skills that ensure the principles of conduct and the quality of care provided. The literature is still incipient in this theme; however, some studies point to education and ethical consultations as strategies to promote an ethical environment.
Professional values, cultural competence, and moral sensitivity of surgical nurses: Mediation analysis and structural equation modeling
Kandemir D and Yüksel S
Developing a framework that illustrates causal relationships and an in-depth comprehension of contextual elements is essential for steering the development of ethical interventions to enhance nurses' ethical decision-making.
A descriptive and interpretive theory of ethical responsibility in public health nursing
Clancy A, Hovden JT and Laholt H
This article presents a descriptive, interpretive theory of ethical responsibility in public health nursing. The theory is based on qualitative empirical studies, a purposeful literature review and meta-ethnography of public health nurses' experiences of ethical responsibility, interpreted within a philosophical framework. Levianasian philosophy provides the main direction for the authors' interpretations. The path for theory development consists of three phases: , ''. The theory illustrates that ethical responsibility in public health nursing is related to the life existentials of temporality and human relationships. Due to blurred boundaries in these essential life structures, public health nurses can experience a sense of satisfaction but also worries, uncertainties and loneliness. The study reveals paradoxical connections between fear and courage, and between freedom, autonomy and a sense of entrapment in responsible relationships. The authors purport that the results of this study are relevant for education and practice and can provide direction for further studies on developing theories of ethical responsibility in other nursing specialities.
Humans: An integrative review exploring dehumanisation in advanced dementia
Bøgmose J, Olivares Bøgeskov BM, Dening T and Martinsen B
People living with advanced dementia risk being seen as someone without personhood in contemporary societies, an understanding that has been described and challenged for decades in dementia scholarly literature. Such perception can be characterised as forms of existential dehumanisation, which still asserts itself in dementia care practices, adversely affecting the ethical and caring aspects of such care. To challenge dehumanisation in dementia care, we must first learn to recognise what foster it in caring relations. Thus, the aim of our study is to identify existing perceptions of care recipients living with advanced dementia, which elicit dehumanising attitudes among formal caregivers. We conducted an integrative review based on Whittemore and Knafl's updated methodology. This allowed us to identify and analyse 26 articles incorporating both qualitative- and quantitative studies as well as theoretical- and grey literature all describing perceptions of care recipients living with dementia that lead to dehumanisation. Studying the darker sides in caring relations was to be beneficial in improving dementia care practices. Through an analytical process five themes that can sprout dehumanising attitudes in caring relations were identified, which include perceiving people living with advanced dementia as (1) absurd, (2) shadow, (3) perilous, (4) void, or (5) repugnant. We argue that these perceptions can be seen as unintentional and stem from a misled embodied perception, which caregivers should learn to recognise and consequently be able to resist through virtue ethics. Our study indicates that challenging dehumanisation is a practical matter of identifying and reacting in a timely way to ones misled embodied perceptions. We suggest the five themes offer a potential means to warn formal caregivers of impending dehumanising attitudes and help them to review how they ethically are thinking and perceiving the person living with advanced dementia.