A mini-review on the international gyrate atrophy symposium 2023: More than meets the eye. Focus on outstanding research questions
Pompe disease: Unmet needs and emerging therapies
Pompe disease is a debilitating and life-threatening disease caused by aberrant accumulation of glycogen resulting from reduced acid alpha-glucosidase activity. The first treatment for Pompe disease, the enzyme replacement therapy, Myozyme® (recombinant human acid alpha-glucosidase, alglucosidase alfa), is a lifesaving treatment for the most severe form of the disease and provided clinically meaningful benefits to patients with milder phenotypes. Nonetheless, many patients display suboptimal responses or clinical decline following years of alglucosidase alfa treatment. The approval of avalglucosidase alfa (Nexviazyme®) and cipaglucosidase alfa (Pombiliti®) with miglustat (Opfolda®) represents a new generation of enzyme replacement therapies seeking to further improve patient outcomes beyond alglucosidase alfa. However, the emergence of a complicated new phenotype with central nervous system involvement following long-term treatment, coupled with known and anticipated unmet needs of patients receiving enzyme replacement therapy, has prompted development of innovative new treatments. This review provides an overview of the challenges of existing treatments and a summary of emerging therapies currently in preclinical or clinical development for Pompe disease and related lysosomal storage disorders. Key treatments include tissue-targeted enzyme replacement therapy, which seeks to enhance enzyme concentration in target tissues such as the central nervous system; substrate reduction therapy, which reduces intracellular glycogen concentrations via novel mechanisms; and gene therapy, which may restore endogenous production of deficient acid alpha-glucosidase. Each of these proposed treatments shows promise as a future therapeutic option to improve quality of life in Pompe disease by more efficiently treating the underlying cause of disease progression: glycogen accumulation.
Imaging improvement in acid sphingomyelinase deficiency on enzyme replacement therapy
Home infusion experience in patients with Pompe disease receiving avalglucosidase alfa during three clinical trials
During three previously reported clinical trials of avalglucosidase alfa in patients with Pompe disease, 17 out of 142 participants were considered by the investigators to be appropriate candidates for home infusion. During their respective trials, these participants received a total of 419 avalglucosidase alfa infusions at home under healthcare professional supervision. They were clinically stable with no history of moderate or severe infusion-associated reactions within at least 12 months prior to starting home infusions. As of February 25, 2022, the 15 participants with late-onset Pompe disease (LOPD) had received between 2 and 48 home infusions and the 2 participants with infantile-onset Pompe disease (IOPD) had received 19 and 20 infusions. Adverse events occurred in 8 (53 %) participants with LOPD and neither of the participants with IOPD. Seven participants with LOPD had a total of 15 non-treatment-related, non-serious adverse events. One participant with LOPD experienced infusion-associated reactions of eyelid edema and flushing during the first home infusion; both were non-serious adverse events classified as grade 1 (mild). Home infusion was later resumed for this participant. Among LOPD participants, event rates for home infusions were comparable to those for clinic infusions: overall adverse events (0.028 vs 0.039 participants with events/infusion, respectively) and adverse events classified as infusion-associated reactions (0.003 vs. 0.006, respectively). No medication errors occurred during home infusion. These data suggest that infusion of avalglucosidase alfa at home is feasible and does not compromise safety for patients who have not experienced an infusion-associated reaction during the preceding 12 months of infusions in a clinical setting. Evaluation of real-world experience with avalglucosidase alfa home infusion in countries where it is already approved is ongoing.
Pegvaliase treatment normalizes blood neurotransmitter metabolites in adults with phenylketonuria
Phenylketonuria (PKU) is caused by deficient activity of phenylalanine hydroxylase (PAH), the enzyme that converts phenylalanine (Phe) to tyrosine (Tyr), leading to a toxic accumulation of Phe and reduced Tyr in the blood and brain. Abnormal Phe and Tyr levels in the brain disrupt normal neurotransmitter biosynthesis and may contribute to the cognitive and psychiatric deficits observed in individuals with PKU. Blood neurotransmitter metabolites (NTMs) may serve as biomarkers that reflect neurotransmitter levels in the brain. In this study, blood NTMs correlated with brain NTMs and neurotransmitters in wild-type and PAH-deficient mice treated with PAH gene therapy. Pegvaliase is an enzyme substitution therapy that lowers blood Phe levels and is approved for individuals with PKU and uncontrolled blood Phe concentrations (>600 μmol/L) despite prior management. The current work evaluated the relationship between blood NTMs and blood Phe in pegvaliase-treated, Phase 3, PRISM-1 (NCT01819727) and PRISM-2 (NCT01889862) study participants (Pegvaliase Group; N = 109). At baseline, individuals in the Pegvaliase Group had lower levels of the NTMs homovanillic acid (HVA), 3-methoxy-4-hydroxyphenyl glycol (MOPEG), and 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid (5HIAA), and higher levels of the NTM phenylacetylglutamine (PAG) than age- and sex-matched healthy controls. PAG levels correlated positively with Phe levels (r = 0.833; p < 0.001), while HVA, MOPEG, and 5HIAA levels correlated negatively with Phe levels (r = -0.588, -0.561, and -0.857, respectively; all p < 0.001) across all timepoints. In participants with longitudinal NTM measurements available at baseline, 12 months, and 24 months (Pegvaliase Subgroup; n = 91), blood NTM levels improved from baseline with pegvaliase treatment at 12 months and 24 months, and median levels were normalized with blood Phe level reductions below 360 μmol/L after 24 months of treatment with pegvaliase, including in participants with blood Phe <30 μmol/L. In conclusion, blood NTM levels correlated with blood Phe levels, and pegvaliase improved blood NTM levels in a large cohort of individuals with PKU.
The role of NMDA-receptor type glutamatergic antagonists dextromethorphan or ketamine in the treatment of nonketotic hyperglycinemia: A critical reassessment
The recognition of glycine as an endogenous ligand at the allosteric activation site of the NMDA-type glutamatergic receptor led to the assumption that the excess glycine in nonketotic hyperglycinemia would result in overactivation of these receptors, and of the proposed use of inhibitors such as dextromethorphan or ketamine as a therapeutic agent. Years later it was recognized that these same receptors have an alternative endogenous activator d-serine, which is markedly decreased in nonketotic hyperglycinemia. This may result in underactivation of these NMDA-type glutamatergic receptors, challenging the earlier hypothesis. Clear clinical evidence of an added therapeutic benefit beyond the use of glycine reduction strategies from use of either dextromethorphan or ketamine in nonketotic hyperglycinemia has not been documented. The systematic use of these NMDA-type receptor antagonists in nonketotic hyperglycinemia should be reevaluated, particularly in light of emerging potential adverse effects.
Response to therapy of creatine transporter deficiency caused by a hypomorphic variant in SLC6A8
Cerebral creatine deficiency syndromes (CCDS) are rare inherited metabolic disorders caused by defective biosynthesis or transport of creatine. These conditions are characterized by reduced accumulation of creatine in the brain, mild to severe intellectual disability, global developmental delay, and speech-language disorders. The amount of brain creatine reduction needed to cause symptoms is not known. Here we report a new patient with creatine transporter deficiency (CTD) who presented at 15 months of age with seizures and global delays with no speech at 3 years of age. Brain MRI was normal, but brain MRS indicated creatine levels reduced to about 20 % of normal. He had normal levels of creatine and guanidinoacetate in plasma, but increased creatine/creatinine ratio in urine. DNA sequencing identified a hemizygous c.832C > T (p.Arg278Cys) variant in the creatine transporter gene SLC6A8. Fibroblasts from this patient had about 25 % of normal creatine transport activity, a value much higher than that measured in patients whose variants introduced premature stop codons in SLC6A8. The child was started on supplements of creatine, glycine, and arginine. His speech improved dramatically, and he had no more seizures, even during episodes of fever. Despite the clinical improvement, a repeat MRS demonstrated similar levels of brain creatine. This study suggests that a reduction in creatine transporter activity to 25 % or less is sufficient to cause symptoms of brain creatine deficiency and that functionally milder forms of CTD might respond to supplements aimed at replenishing brain creatine.
Assessment of genes involved in lysosomal diseases using the ClinGen clinical validity framework
Lysosomal diseases (LDs) are a heterogeneous group of rare genetic disorders that result in impaired lysosomal function, leading to progressive multiorgan system dysfunction. Accurate diagnosis is paramount to initiating targeted therapies early in the disease process in addition to providing prognostic information and appropriate support for families. In recent years, genomic sequencing technologies have become the first-line approach in the diagnosis of LDs. Understanding the clinical validity of the role of a gene in a disease is critical for the development of genomic technologies, such as which genes to include on next generation sequencing panels, and the interpretation of results from exome and genome sequencing. To this aim, the ClinGen Lysosomal Diseases Gene Curation Expert Panel utilized a semi-quantitative framework incorporating genetic and experimental evidence to assess the clinical validity of the 56 LD-associated genes on the Lysosomal Disease Network's list. Here, we describe the results, and the key themes and challenges encountered.
Multi-omic analysis of a mucolipidosis II neuronal cell model uncovers involvement of pathways related to neurodegeneration and drug metabolism
Defining the molecular consequences of lysosomal dysfunction in neuronal cell types remains an area of investigation that is needed to understand many underappreciated phenotypes associated with lysosomal disorders. Here we characterize GNPTAB-knockout DAOY medulloblastoma cells using different genetic and proteomic approaches, with a focus on how altered gene expression and cell surface abundance of glycoproteins may explain emerging neurological issues in individuals with GNPTAB-related disorders, including mucolipidosis II (ML II) and mucolipidosis IIIα/β (ML IIIα/β). The two knockout clones characterized demonstrated all the biochemical hallmarks of this disease, including loss of intracellular glycosidase activity due to impaired mannose 6-phosphate-dependent lysosomal sorting, lysosomal cholesterol accumulation, and increased markers of autophagic dysfunction. RNA sequencing identified altered transcript abundance of several neuronal markers and genes involved in drug metabolism and transport, and neurodegeneration-related pathways. Using selective exo-enzymatic labeling (SEEL) coupled with proteomics to profile cell surface glycoproteins, we demonstrated altered abundance of several glycoproteins in the knockout cells. Most striking was increased abundance of the amyloid precursor protein and apolipoprotein B, indicating that loss of GNPTAB function in these cells corresponds with elevation in proteins associated with neurodegeneration. The implication of these findings on lysosomal disease pathogenesis and the emerging neurological manifestations of GNPTAB-related disorders is discussed.
Findings from the individualized management of a patient with Acyl-CoA Oxidase-1 (ACOX1) deficiency: A bedside-to-bench-to-bedside strategy
Acyl-CoA Oxidase-1 (ACOX1) deficiency (MIM 264470) is an autosomal recessive disease characterized by impairments in the desaturation of acyl-CoAs to 2-trans-enoyl-CoAs, which is the first step in the catalysis of the β-oxidative breakdown of very long chain fatty acids (VLCFA) occuring in peroxisomes. The deleterious accumulation of VLCFA in several organs, including the brain, is a key biochemical feature of this disease which has devastating neurological consequences. ACOX1 deficiency is ultra-rare; as such, few studies have been conducted to determine the leading causes of symptoms or uncover new therapeutics. When confronted with one such case, we decided to bring drug discovery tools to the patient's bedside in an attempt to identify a cure. A skin biopsy was performed on a young patient with ACOX1 deficiency, following which screening technologies and mass spectrometry analysis techniques were applied to design a cellular assay that enabled the direct measurement of the effect of small molecules on the patient's primary fibroblasts. This approach is particularly well adapted to inherited metabolic disorders such as ACOX1 deficiency. Through the evaluation of a proprietary library of repurposable drugs, we found that the anthelmintic drug niclosamide led to a significant reduction in VLCFA in vitro. This drug was subsequently administered to the patient for more than six years. This study outlines the screening and drug selection processes. Additionally, we present our comprehensive clinical and biochemical findings that aided in understanding the patient's natural history and analysis of the progression of the patient's symptoms throughout the treatment period. Although the patient's overall lifespan was extended compared to the average age at death in severe early onset cases of ACOX1 deficiency, we did not observe any definitive evidence of clinical or biochemical improvement during niclosamide treatment. Nonetheless, our study shows a good safety profile of long-term niclosamide administration in a child with a rare neurodegenerative disease, and illustrates the potential of individualized therapeutic strategies in the management of inherited metabolic disorders, which could benefit both patients and the broader scientific and medical communities.
cPMP rescue of a neonate with severe molybdenum cofactor deficiency after serendipitous early diagnosis, and characterisation of a novel MOCS1 variant
We report the first, and so far, only index patient with neonatal onset MoCD type A who was diagnosed and treated early enough with cPMP to avoid severe brain injury and disability. The child presented with hypoglycemia at the age of 10 h and was diagnosed because of the incidental finding of severely decreased L-cystine in plasma. Due to a high level of awareness and excellent co-operation between metabolic laboratory and clinical services, cPMP substitution could be initiated before severe encephalopathy set in, and the child subsequently had a normal motor development. The child has been continued on daily substitution with cPMP until today (age 7 years) and has shown a satisfying long-term developmental outcome. Long-term follow-up, however, revealed significant communication difficulties and cognitive abilities in the range of mild to moderate learning disability. The severity of the metabolic disease was confirmed by the extent of biochemical abnormalities and further functional characterisation of the underlying genetic variants. This case provides further evidence that cPMP substitution does significantly alter the disease course when applied early enough. Postnatal treatment in this case was not sufficient to enable an entirely normal cognitive development, despite sustained complete normalization of the biochemical abnormalities.
Progressive liver disease and dysregulated glycogen metabolism in murine GSD IX γ2 models human disease
Hepatic glycogen storage disease type IX γ2 (GSD IX γ2) is a severe, liver-specific subtype of GSD IX. While all patients with hepatic GSD IX present with similar symptoms, over 95 % of patients with GSD IX γ2 progress to liver fibrosis and cirrhosis. Despite disease severity, the long-term natural history of GSD IX γ2 liver disease progression is not known. Our lab previously characterized the Phkg2 mouse model at 3 months of age, demonstrating that the mouse recapitulates the early liver disease phenotype of GSD IX γ2. To understand how liver disease progresses in GSD IX γ2, we characterized the mouse model through 24 months of age. Our study showed for the first time that GSD IX γ2 mice develop liver fibrosis that progresses to cirrhosis. Importantly, we observed that the progression of liver fibrosis is associated with an initial elevation and subsequent decrease of key GSD biomarkers - the latter being a finding that is often considered to be an improvement of disease in patients. In recognition of the unique liver fibrosis pattern and to support future therapeutic investigations using this model, we developed a novel scoring system for GSD IX γ2 mouse liver pathology. Lastly, this work introduces evidence of a dysregulated glycogen metabolism pathway which can serve as an endpoint for future therapeutic evaluation. As we await longitudinal clinical natural history data, these findings greatly expand our understanding of liver disease manifestations in GSD IX γ2 and have notable clinical applications.
Recent developments in the analytical approaches of acyl-CoAs to assess their role in mitochondrial fatty acid oxidation disorders
Fatty acid oxidation disorders (FAOD) are inborn errors of metabolism that occur due to deficiency of specific enzyme activities and transporter proteins involved in the mitochondrial metabolism of fatty acids, causing a deficiency in ATP production. The identification of suitable biomarkers plays a crucial role in predicting the future risk of disease and monitoring responses to therapies. Acyl-CoAs are directly involved in the steps of fatty acid oxidation and are the primary biomarkers associated with FAOD. However, acyl-CoAs are not used as diagnostic biomarkers in hospitals and clinics as they are present intracellularly with low endogenous levels. Additionally, the analytical method development of acyl-CoAs is quite challenging due to diverse physicochemical properties and instability. Hence, secondary biomarkers such as acylcarnitines are used for the identification of FAOD. In this review, the focus is on the analytical techniques that have evolved over the years for the identification and quantitation of acyl-CoAs. Among these techniques, liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry clearly has an advantage in terms of sensitivity and selectivity. Stable isotope labeling by essential nutrients in cell culture (SILEC) enables the generation of labeled internal standards. Each acyl-CoA species has a distinct pattern of instability and degradation, and the use of appropriately matched internal standards can compensate for such issues. Although significant progress has been made in measuring acyl-CoAs, more efforts are needed for bringing these technical advancements to hospitals and clinics. This review also highlights the difficulties involved in the routine use of acyl-CoAs as a diagnostic biomarker and some of the measures that can be adopted by clinics and hospitals for overcoming these limitations.
Developing a scoring system for gene curation prioritization in lysosomal diseases
Diseases caused by lysosomal dysfunction often exhibit multisystemic involvement, resulting in substantial morbidity and mortality. Ensuring accurate diagnoses for individuals with lysosomal diseases (LD) is of great importance, especially with the increasing prominence of genetic testing as a primary diagnostic method. As the list of genes associated with LD continues to expand due to the use of more comprehensive tests such as exome and genome sequencing, it is imperative to understand the clinical validity of the genes, as well as identify appropriate genes for inclusion in multi-gene testing and sequencing panels. The Clinical Genome Resource (ClinGen) works to determine the clinical importance of genes and variants to support precision medicine. As part of this work, ClinGen has developed a semi-quantitative framework to assess the strength of evidence for the role of a gene in a disease. Given the diversity in gene composition across LD panels offered by various laboratories and the evolving comprehension of genetic variants affecting secondary lysosomal functions, we developed a scoring system to define LD (Lysosomal Disease Scoring System - LDSS). This system sought to aid in the prioritization of genes for clinical validity curation and assess their suitability for LD-targeted sequencing panels.
Severity-adjusted evaluation of initial dialysis on short-term health outcomes in urea cycle disorders
In individuals with urea cycle disorders (UCDs) and neonatal disease onset, extracorporeal detoxification by continuous kidney replacement therapy is considered the therapeutic method of choice in addition to metabolic emergency treatment to resolve hyperammonemic decompensation. However, the indications for the initiation of dialysis are heterogeneously implemented transnationally, thereby hampering our understanding of (optimal) short-term health outcomes.
Maple syrup urine disease diagnosis in Brazilian patients by massive parallel sequencing
Biallelic pathogenic variants cause maple syrup urine disease (MSUD) in one of the branched-chain α-keto acid dehydrogenase (BCKDH) complex genes (BCKDHA, BCKDHB, DBT, DLD, and PPM1K) leading to the accumulation of leucine, isoleucine, and valine. This study aimed to perform a molecular diagnosis of Brazilian patients with MSUD using gene panels and massive parallel sequencing. Eighteen Brazilian patients with a biochemical diagnosis of MSUD were analyzed by massive parallel sequencing in the Ion PGM Torrent Server using a gene panel with the BCKDHA, BCKDHB, and DBT genes. The American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics guidelines were used to determine variant pathogenicity. Thirteen patients had both variants found by massive parallel sequencing, whereas 3 patients had only one variant found. In 2 patients, the variants were not found by this analysis. These 5 patients required additional Sanger sequencing to confirm their genotype. Twenty-five pathogenic variants were identified in the 3 MSUD-related genes (BCKDHA, BCKDHB, and DBT). Most variants were present in the BCKDHB gene, and no common variants were found. Nine novel variants were observed: c.922 A > G, c.964C > A, and c.1237 T > C in the BCKDHA gene; and c.80_90dup, c.384delA, c.478 A > T, c.528C > G, c.977 T > C, and c.1039-2 A > G in the BCKDHB gene. All novel variants were classified as pathogenic. Molecular modeling of the novel variants indicated that the binding of monomers was affected in the BCKDH complex tetramer, which could lead to a change in the stability and activity of the enzyme. Massive parallel sequencing with targeted gene panels seems to be a cost-effective method that can provide a molecular diagnosis of MSUD.
Development of a signs and symptoms outcome measure for caregivers of patients with methylmalonic acidemia and propionic acidemia (MMAPAQ)
Methylmalonic acidemia (MMA) and propionic acidemia (PA) are rare inborn errors of metabolism with shared signs and symptoms that are associated with significant morbidity and mortality. No disease-specific clinical outcomes assessment instruments for MMA and/or PA currently exist to capture the patient perspective in clinical trials. Because patients with these conditions are generally young and have cognitive impairments, an observer-reported outcome (ObsRO) instrument is crucial. We report results from qualitative research supporting development of the Methylmalonic Acidemia and Propionic Acidemia Questionnaire (MMAPAQ), a signs and symptoms ObsRO measure for caregivers of patients with MMA and/or PA.
Genotype-phenotype findings in patients with mucopolysaccharidosis II from the Hunter Outcome Survey
This study investigated the relationship between mucopolysaccharidosis II (MPS II) iduronate-2-sulfatase gene (IDS) variants and phenotypic characteristics, particularly cognitive impairment, using data from the Hunter Outcome Survey (HOS) registry.
Base editing of the GLB1 gene is therapeutic in GM1 gangliosidosis patient-derived cells
GM1 gangliosidosis is an autosomal recessive neurodegenerative lysosomal storage disease caused by pathogenic variants in the GLB1 gene, limiting the production of active lysosomal β-galactosidase. Phenotypic heterogeneity is due in part to variant type, location within GLB1, and the amount of residual enzyme activity; in the most severe form, death occurs in infancy. With no FDA approved therapeutics, development of efficacious strategies for the disease is pivotal. CRISPR/Cas based approaches have revolutionized precision medicine and have been indispensable to the development of treatments for several monogenic disorders with bespoke strategies central to current research pipelines. We used CRISPR/Cas-adenine base editing to correct the GLB1 c.380G>A (p.Cys127Tyr) variant in patient-derived dermal fibroblasts compound heterozygous with the GLB1 c.481T>G (p.Trp161Gly) pathogenic variant. Nucleofection of plasmids encoding the target sgRNA and ABEmax restored the canonical guanine (32.2 ± 2.2 % of the target allele) and synthesis of active β-galactosidase. Analysis of cellular markers of pathology revealed normalization of both primary glycoconjugate storage and lysosomal pathology. Furthermore, analysis of off-target sites nominated by the in silico tools Cas-OFFinder and/or CRISTA revealed no significant editing or indels. This study supports the use of CRISPR/Cas-based approaches for the treatment of GM1 gangliosidosis, and provides foundational data for future translational studies.
Standardized emergency protocols to improve the management of patients with suspected or confirmed inherited metabolic disorders (IMDs): An initiative of the French IMDs Healthcare Network for Rare Diseases
Patients with inherited metabolic disorders (IMDs) may require emergency hospital care to prevent life-threatening situations such as metabolic decompensation. To date, over one thousand different rare IMDs have been identified, which means that healthcare professionals (HCPs) initiating emergency treatment may not be familiar with these conditions. The objective of this initiative was to provide HCPs with practical guidance for the acute management of children and adults with IMDs who need emergency care, regardless of the underlying reason.
Systemic complications of Aicardi Goutières syndrome using real-world data
Aicardi Goutières Syndrome (AGS) is a rare genetic interferonopathy associated with diverse multisystemic complications. A critical gap exists in our understanding of its longitudinal, systemic disease burden, complicated by delayed diagnosis. To address this need, real-world data extracted from existing medical records were used to characterize the longitudinal disease burden.