Therapeutic Innovation & Regulatory Science

Principles for Evaluating the Efficacy and Safety of Ceramic Dental Implants in Japan
Hara T, Sato Y, Tanishiro H, Tamaki Y, Baba S, Hirose E, Yoshida B, Watanabe K, Nishikawa G, Okuda D, Murakami M, Niwa Y and Kondoh M
Recent progress in materials chemistry has resulted in the development of several ceramic materials that are now being used in dental implants. The advantages of ceramic materials over conventional metallic materials are that they do not induce allergic reactions in individuals with metal allergies, they do not interfere with magnetic resonance imaging, and they provide improved esthetics. In addition, some ceramic materials are tougher than metallic materials and less brittle. However, despite these advantages, few ceramic dental implant materials are currently approved for use in Japan. In FY2022, the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare of Japan commissioned a project called the "Project for the Development of a Guideline for the Evaluation of Ceramic Dental Implants," the goal of which was to consider how best to facilitate swift clinical development and approval of emerging ceramic dental implant materials. At a meeting of experts from professional societies, related industry organizations, and government agencies, the issues related to evaluation of the efficacy and safety of ceramic implant were discussed. Here, we summarize the outcomes of that meeting as a set of principles for the premarketing evaluation of ceramic dental implant materials in Japan.
Review of the European Union Clinical Trials Regulation: Key Early Learnings from the United Kingdom Drug Information Association Medical Writing Committee
Koo DDH, Taylor E, Hooper IT, Khaled SF, Fagan V, Turner H and Buttery HL
The European Union Clinical Trials Regulation (EU CTR) provides new regulatory requirements for the preparation and submission of clinical trial documents. The United Kingdom Drug Information Association Medical Writing (UK DIA MW) Committee, with members from across the pharmaceutical industry, have reviewed the EU CTR and in this report, provide expert guidance on writing documents for submission in the EU CTR Clinical Trials Information System (CTIS) portal. Medical writers should be aware that the Investigator's Brochure containing the Reference Safety Information (RSI) must align with the annual safety report, and the RSI format must comply closely with the EU CTR. For clinical study protocols, medical writers should prepare a single integrated EU protocol that receives consolidated approvals from all participating EU member states, with different versions of a protocol for different EU member states no longer permitted. This report also provides details of experiences and recommendations on protocol synopses from the UK DIA MW Committee. In addition, plain language summaries are new EU CTR documents required for each study presenting summaries of clinical trial results for laypersons. Some of these documents will be published in the publicly accessible CTIS portal which has created concerns amongst many companies who are keen to protect commercially confidential information (CCI). Medical writers may help reduce CCI through lean writing, but specifically identifying CCI may require specialist legal evaluation. This report by the UK DIA MW Committee highlights the key processes for medical writers to ensure compliance with the EU CTR when preparing documents for submission to the CTIS portal.
An Analysis of the Food and Drug Administration Manufacturer and User Facility Device Experience Database for MAGnetic Expansion Control Spinal Rods
Filan J, Bowey A and Joyce T
MAGnetic Expansion Control (MAGEC) rods can prevent repeated lengthening operations for scoliosis patients. However, there have been several Field Safety Notices issued, including a worldwide product recall due to actuator endcap separation. We aimed to review adverse events reported to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regarding MAGEC rods, focusing on MAGEC X.
Better Medicines for Children: Lessons Learnt and Share Learnings at the EFGCP Annual Paediatric Conferences
Corriol-Rohou S, Fürst-Recktenwald SI, Davies EH, Dehlinger-Kremer M and Turner MA
For many years, the European Forum for Good Clinical Practice (EFGCP) Children Medicines Working Party has organised a Paediatric conference annually. In the past, this event was organised jointly with the European Medicines Agency who was used to host it, along with the Drug Information Association (DIA). This conference is the opportunity for all involved in paediatric drug development, i.e., regulators, HTA bodies, patients' representatives, academia and industry, to share learnings and raise awareness about new regulatory requirements of interest to optimise paediatric drug development. The theme of the 2021 conference was "Challenges and Solutions - the path forward" while in 2022 it focused on "Progress made and Continuing Challenges". Because of the COVID-19 pandemic these two conferences were organised virtually. However, this has not impacted the attendance and value of the conference, since because of a broad and attractive agenda there was a wide stakeholder participation, which provided a compendious overview of the leading issues to improve children's access to innovative medicines.
Testing the Feasibility of a Digital Point of Care Solution for the Trusted Near Real-Time Bidirectional Exchange of Novel and Informative Adverse Event Information
Powell G, Kara V, Naranjo D, Kulkarni M, Best-Sule K, Coster T, Bonafede M, Gangadhar S, Kallenbach L and Bate A
A digital point-of-care solution was implemented to test the feasibility of near-real-time bi-directional communication between pharmacovigilance experts (PVEs) and healthcare professionals (HCPs) for exchanging unique and informative adverse event (AE) information. The solution was implemented in a commercially available electronic health record (EHR) system/platform, no direct contact between PVEs and the HCPs was possible. The Clinical Affairs team of the EHR vendor was used as an intermediary to ensure appropriate information was exchanged while protecting HCP and patient privacy. The study yielded 9 drug-event pairs of interest (AEI), 2 of which were confirmed as AEs by the HCP. On average it took 20.6 h to receive initial AEI information and 58.8 h to receive follow-up information, which represents a 96% reduction in time compared to current methods. Both interactions provided unique data that would not have been collected otherwise leading to the PVE being able to appropriately determine a potential causal association. This study successfully demonstrated the feasibility of using a compliant, bi-directional, digitally enabled clinical communication channel at the point of care to complement existing pharmacovigilance activities.
Comparison of Borrowing Methods for Incorporating Historical Data in Single-Arm Phase II Clinical Trials
Urru S, Verbeni M, Azzolina D, Baldi I and Berchialla P
Over the last few years, many efforts have been made to leverage historical information in clinical trials. Incorporating historical data into current trials allows for a more efficient design, smaller studies, or shorter duration and may potentially increase the relative amount of information on efficacy and safety. Despite these advantages, it is crucial to select external data sources appropriately to avoid introducing potential bias into the new study. This is where borrowing methods become useful. We illustrate and compare the latest methods of borrowing historical data in a single-arm phase II clinical trial setting, examining their impact on statistical power and type I error.
Turning the Page on Hardcopy Risk Management Plan Educational Materials: Digitalization Made Possible
Ng A, Celo AN and Fernandes B
'Risk Management Plan Educational Materials' (RMP EMs) are additional risk minimization measures (aRMMs) intended to prevent or reduce the occurrence of adverse reactions associated with the exposure to a medicine, or to reduce their severity or impact on the patient. While the healthcare sector is embracing various digital tools and platforms for educational and/or awareness building purposes, paper-based materials have remained the mainstay approach for implementation of aRMMs by pharmaceutical companies. Novartis in Singapore conducted a pilot on the feasibility of distributing electronic copies of RMP EMs (e-RMP). Post-pilot, e-RMP was officially implemented in Novartis Singapore. A year following the launch of e-RMP, a survey was performed with healthcare professionals (HCPs) to understand end-users' experience. The survey responses revealed a general preference by both HCPs and patients towards e-RMP. Digital methods of delivering educational aRMMs offer great benefits over traditional paper-based programs. e-RMP significantly reduces the time needed for updated RMP EMs to reach HCPs and their patients/caregivers. This is important to ensure that HCPs and patients/caregivers are made aware of any updates in key safety messages of the products in a timely manner to ultimately ensure patient safety. The successful transition to digital solutions requires purposeful collaborations between key stakeholders of the healthcare ecosystem including regulatory authorities, pharmaceutical companies, HCPs, patients and caregivers. This article aims to provide insights on the digitalization journey of e-RMP, a case study in Singapore, outlining the value but also some of the challenges faced during this transformation.
Research on Core Competency Elements of Clinical Investigators
Wang X, Zhao S, Yang H, Miao M, An S and Yao W
To construct a competency model for clinical investigators involved in the process of new drug development, providing a reference for the training, selection and assessment of clinical investigators.
A Clustering Ensemble Method for Drug Safety Signal Detection in Post-Marketing Surveillance
Chakraborty S and Tiwari R
Post-marketing surveillance refers to the process of monitoring the safety of drugs once they reach the market, after the successful completion of clinical trials. In this work, we investigate a computational approach using data mining tools to detect safety signals from post-market safety databases, or in other words, to identify adverse events (AEs) with disproportionately high reporting rates compared to other AEs, associated with a particular drug or a drug class. Essentially, we view this as a problem of cluster analysis-based anomaly detection on post-market safety data, where the goal is to 'unsupervisedly' detect the anomalous or the signal AEs. Our findings demonstrate the potential of using a clustering ensemble method to detect drug safety signals. It employs multiple clustering or anomaly detection algorithms, followed by a performance comparison of the candidate algorithms based on a collection of appropriate measures of goodness of clustering results. The method is general enough to include any number of clustering or anomaly detection algorithms and goodness measures, and performs better than any of the candidate algorithms in identifying the signal AEs. Extensive simulation studies illustrate that the ensemble method detects the AE signals from synthetic post-market safety datasets pretty accurately across the different scenarios explored. Based on the cases reported to the FDA Adverse Event Reporting System (FAERS) between 2013 and 2022, we further demonstrate that the ensemble method successfully identifies and confirms most of the adverse events that are known to occur most frequently in reaction to antiepileptic drugs and -lactam antibiotics.
Pediatric-Specific Drug Loss Issue in Japan: Comparison of Pediatric Development Status Between Japan and the United States
Osako R, Matsumaru N and Tsukamoto K
The lack of label information for the pediatric population has been a global issue, leading to the introduction of several countermeasures by major health authorities. Despite various efforts by Japanese health authorities, some drugs are approved only for adults in Japan, while the United States (US) label includes information on pediatric usage for the same drugs. This suggests a potential for pediatric-specific drug loss in Japan, where overall drug loss has recently become a major concern.
Provision of Drug Information Using Database Surveys-Enhancing Clinical Information for Patients with Specific Backgrounds
Nakai K, Ikeda M and Nomura Y
Hypocalcemia Event Associated with Denosumab: A Real-World Study from FDA Adverse Event Reporting System (FAERS) Database
Gao S, Zheng G, He Z, Chen L, Yan D, Lai Z, Cai T and Hu S
Denosumab is widely used for osteoporosis and cancer treatment. However, hypocalcemia induced by denosumab is a frequent adverse event. The objective of this study is to comprehensively investigate the safety signals and the occurrence of hypocalcemia in real-world patient cases reported through the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Adverse Event Reporting System (FAERS).
Open Innovation and Regulatory Challenges in New Modality Development: The Pivotal Role of Contract Development and Manufacturing Organisations in Advancing Antibody Drugs
Yoshiura H, Kawata Y and Sengoku S
Ensuring regulatory-compliant manufacturing capability is an essential challenge for new treatment modalities, but its internalisation is not easy for pharmaceutical companies, especially start-ups. This study examines the functions and requirements of contracted development and manufacturing organisations (CDMOs) using the development process of antibody medicines as a case study.
Subsequent Indications in Oncology Drugs: Pathways, Timelines, and the Inflation Reduction Act
Patterson JA, Motyka J, Salih R, Nordyke R, O'Brien JM and Campbell JD
Recent research has raised questions about potential unintended consequences of the Inflation Reduction Act's Drug Price Negotiation Program (DPNP), suggesting that the timelines introduced by the law may reduce manufacturer incentives to invest in post-approval research towards additional indications. Given the role of multiple indications in expanding treatment options in patients with cancer, IRA-related changes to development incentives are especially relevant in oncology. This study aimed to describe heterogeneous drug-level trajectories and timelines of subsequent indications in a cohort of recently approved, multi-indication oncology drugs, including overall, across subgroups of drugs characterized by the timing and pace of additional indications, and by drug type (i.e., small molecule vs. biologic).
Pharmaceutical Company's Choices of Indication for the First Clinical Projects in Oncological Drug Development in the United States
Wu C and Ono S
We analyzed factors shaping the choice of the lead indication (i.e., cancer type) in the first clinical development projects of new oncological drugs in the United States (US), and how the type of pharmaceutical company is related to this choice. We selected 576 new clinical development projects in the US since 2000 for analysis. These projects were characterized according to three potential perspectives detected by multiple correspondence analysis: the morbidity of the cancer type which corresponds to market size of each cancer type, the company's previous experience with the cancer type, and the company's attitude to development risks. Mega firms tend to choose cancer types with higher morbidity (and large-market), previously experienced cancer types, while diverse small firms choose both major and rare cancers and both high- and low-risk projects, indicating that different sizes of firms utilize different development entry patterns. Common tendencies concerning the choice of lead indication were found across all companies. Cancer types the company had developed and launched in the past were more likely to be chosen; cancer types with high five-year survival rates and those with high competition were less likely to be chosen. The study showed that pharmaceutical companies seem to enter clinical development from cancer types where they can demonstrate their strengths and advantages through experience, depending on each cancer type's different market sizes and development difficulties. The results could provide clues for considering what support measures and incentives are appropriate to balance the efficiency of industrial development and the fulfillment of society's unmet medical needs.
Expanding Pharmaceutical Access Via Over the Counter Drugs
Jouaneh TMM, Gowda V and Miller BJ
This commentary addresses the recent U.S. Food & Drug Administration (FDA) proposed rule to expand access to nonprescription drugs through additional conditions of nonprescription use (ACNU). It surveys the various pathways to market for pharmaceutical products, noting the distinct requirements for over-the-counter (OTC) products differentiating them from prescription products. It subsequently reviews the ACNU proposed rule, weighing its potential benefits against possible limitations. With a view towards the future, the ACNU proposed rule is acknowledged as part of a longstanding tradition to expand drug channels in a risk-stratified fashion with increasing clinical oversight to address in tandem increasing consumer risks. Finally, the proposed rule also serves as a potential prelude for a future behind the counter drug pathway.
Pharmacometrics-Enhanced Bayesian Borrowing for Pediatric Extrapolation - A Case Study of the DINAMO Trial
Sailer MO, Neubacher D, Johnston C, Rogers J, Wiens M, Pérez-Pitarch A, Tartakovsky I, Marquard J and Laffel LM
Bayesian borrowing analyses have an important role in the design and analysis of pediatric trials. This paper describes use of a prespecified Pharmacometrics Enhanced Bayesian Borrowing (PEBB) analysis that was conducted to overcome an expectation for reduced statistical power in the pediatric DINAMO trial due to a greater than expected variability in the primary endpoint. The DINAMO trial assessed the efficacy and safety of an empagliflozin dosing regimen versus placebo and linagliptin versus placebo on glycemic control (change in HbA1c over 26 weeks) in young people with type 2 diabetes (T2D). Previously fitted pharmacokinetic and exposure-response models for empagliflozin and linagliptin based on available historical data in adult and pediatric patients with T2D were used to simulate participant data and derive the informative component of a Bayesian robust mixture prior distribution. External experts and representatives from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration provided recommendations to determine the effective sample size of the prior and the weight of the informative prior component. Separate exposure response-based Bayesian borrowing analyses for empagliflozin and linagliptin showed posterior mean and 95% credible intervals that were consistent with the trial results. Sensitivity analyses with a full range of alternative weights were also performed. The use of PEBB in this analysis combined advantages of mechanistic modeling of pharmacometric differences between adults and young people with T2D, with advantages of partial extrapolation through Bayesian dynamic borrowing. Our findings suggest that the described PEBB approach is a promising option to optimize the power for future pediatric trials.
Expert Consensus Recommendations on a Biosimilars Value Framework for the Gulf Cooperation Council Countries
Alnaqbi KA, Al-Jedai A, Farghaly M, Omair MA, Hamad A, Abutiban FMA, Shirawi AA, Rayes HA, Aldallal S, Fahmy S and Simoens S
This paper aims to develop a biosimilar value framework with local stakeholders in Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries.
Abstract Versus Concrete Risk Identification in Clinical Research in Japan: Randomized and Prospective Pilot Research on the Effect of Risk Reduction Activities in a Risk-Based Approach
Kondo H, Chiu SW, Hayashi Y, Takahashi N and Yamaguchi T
The risk-based approach (RBA) of clinical trial was first introduced in 2011-2012. RBA necessitates implementing risk reduction activities that are proportionate to risk in order to reduce avoidable quality issues. However, there is no consistent methodology or research for identifying and evaluating risks and planning risk reduction activities. We aimed to evaluate risk reduction activities and their effects by using two risk identification and evaluation methods.
Paediatric Drug Development in Japan: Current Status and Future Challenges
Inagaki R and Narukawa M
Until around 2000, the number of medicinal products labelled for paediatric use was limited worldwide. Regulatory measures to promote paediatric drug development in the US and Europe and the establishment of an international guideline (ICH-E11) have led to an increase in the number of paediatric labels. In Japan, efforts have been made to promote the development of paediatric drugs. This study was aimed to examine whether these supportive efforts are successful in Japan.
Experimental Study of the Promotional Implications of Proprietary Prescription Drug Names
Peinado S, O'Donoghue AC, Betts KR, Paquin RS, Giombi K, Arnold JE, Kelly BJ and Davis C
The meaning and characteristics embedded in proprietary drug names have the potential to affect name recall, perceptions of drug benefits and risks, and attitudes toward a drug. In this study, we examined: (1) whether names that reference the drug's medical indication affect consumers' and primary care physicians' (PCPs') perceptions of the drug and (2) whether names that overstate the drug's efficacy affect consumers' and PCPs' perceptions of the drug.