Journal of Mental Health Policy and Economics

Cost-Effectiveness of Digital Preventive Parent Training for Early Childhood Disruptive Behaviour
Rissanen E, Kuvaja-Köllner V and Kankaanpää E
Childhood disruptive behaviour disorder associates with various, also costly problems. Parent training is effective in reducing childhood disruptive behaviour. Only a few studies have evaluated the cost-effectiveness of digital parent training in reducing children's disruptive behaviour.
Mental Health Expenditure in Canada
Milliken O, Wang H, Benda MC, Dinh T and Diener A
Mental ill-health-illness or conditions related to mental health, including dementia, schizophrenia, mood (affective) disorders, and mental and behaviour disorders due to psychoactive substance and alcohol use - places a significant burden on society in terms of economic, health, and social costs. Focusing on direct health care costs, estimated expenditures on treating mental health conditions accounted for up to 14% of total health expenditures across 12 OECD countries over the period of 2003 to 2010.
Relationship of Cryptocurrency Trading to Quality of Life, Sleep and Stress Levels in Academics
Uçar M, Yildiz M, Çiftci N and Aylaz R
Cryptocurrency trading has become popular with a large section of society, and the number of investors is increasing daily. It is critical to address the health impacts of cryptocurrency trading. Of particular importance is the issue of how such trading affects mental health. Research should be conducted on this topic, and where necessary, national governments should develop policies to combat these effects.
Maternal Depression and Physical Health of Under-Five Children in Turkey
Aydilek G and Karaoğlan D
Maternal depression is the most prevalent mental health problem worldwide, especially in low- and middle-income countries. It impairs the cognitive, physical, and social abilities of mothers and disturbs effective parenting practices. Therefore, the consequences of mental, physical, and social suffering are not limited to the mother herself but are transmitted to future generations by negatively affecting the child's health.
PERSPECTIVE: A Fireside Chat about Global Mental Health with Dr. Esther Duflo, Nobel Laureate in Economics
Lê Cook B and Duflo E
Dr. Esther Duflo, Nobel Laureate in Economics, and co-founder and co-director of the Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab (J-PAL) sat down with Dr. Benjamin Cook for a "fireside chat" at the 12th National Institute of Mental Health Global Mental Health Research Without Borders Conference. Dr. Duflo discussed J-PAL's efforts to develop and test interventions for improving mental health and how cash transfer programs can be used to improve mental health. She also discussed the importance of using randomized control trials (RCTs) in shaping global mental health initiatives. Dr. Duflo shared insights from projects addressing loneliness among older individuals in India, secondary school scholarships in Ghana, and other studies that have informed social policies. Looking forward, she discusses climate change as a threat to the reductions in poverty realized in the last 30 years and encourages the expansion of networks of research and policy collaborations to improve global health.
PERSPECTIVE: Implications of Recent Health Policies for Women's Reproductive Mental Health
Zivin K and Courant A
The economic cost of perinatal mood and anxiety disorders (PMADs) is high and includes the cost of reduced maternal economic productivity, more preterm births, and increases in other maternal mental health expenditures. PMADs also substantially contribute the cost of maternal morbidity. This paper offers a discussion of the quality-of-care cascade model of PMADs, which outlines care pathways that people typically face as well as gaps and unmet needs that frequently happen along the way. The model uses the US health system as an example. A discussion of international implications follows.
Effectiveness of Antidepressants in Combination with Psychotherapy
Alemi F, Soylu TG, Cannon M and McCandless C
Consensus-guidelines for prescribing antidepressants recommend that clinicians should be vigilant to match antidepressants to patient's medical history but provide no specific advice on which antidepressant is best for a given medical history.
The Economic Burden of Chronic Psychotic Disorders: An Incidence-based Cost-of-Illness Approach
de Oliveira C and Tanner B
The economic burden of chronic psychotic disorders is substantial. However, few studies have employed an incidence based approach to estimate the economic burden of chronic psychotic disorders. Furthermore, the existing work has mainly used models populated with data obtained from published literature, making several assumptions to estimate incidence-based costs.
PERSPECTIVE: A Path to Value-Based Insurance Design for Mental Health Services
Freed MC, Humensky JL and Arean PA
Aligning cost of mental health care with expected clinical and functional benefits of that care would incentivize the delivery of high value treatments and services. In turn, ineffective or untested care could still be offered but at costs high enough to offset the delivery of high value care.
PERSPECTIVE: Health Economic Interests at NIMH and NIDA to Improve Delivery of Behavioral Health Services
Humensky JL, Duffy SQ, Cubillos L, Freed MC and Rupp A
Effective financing mechanisms are essential to ensuring that people can access and utilize effective treatments and services. Financing mechanisms are needed not only to pay for the delivery of those treatments and services, but also ancillary costs, while also keeping care affordable.
Financial Sustainability of Novel Delivery Models in Behavioral Health Treatment
Hodgkin D, Horgan CM, Jordan Brown S, Bart G and Stewart MT
In the US, much of the research into new intervention and delivery models for behavioral health care is funded by research institutes and foundations, typically through grants to develop and test the new interventions. The original grant funding is typically time-limited. This implies that eventually communities, clinicians, and others must find resources to replace the grant funding -otherwise the innovation will not be adopted. Diffusion is challenged by the continued dominance in the US of fee-for-service reimbursement, especially for behavioral health care.
COVID-19, Mental Health, and Mental Health Treatment among Adults
Zuvekas SH
The COVID-19 pandemic has been widely reported to have increased symptoms of anxiety, depression, and other mental health issues. It may also have significantly disrupted continuity of treatment for existing patients and made access for those newly seeking care more difficult at a time when treatment needs are higher.
Employer-Provided and Self-Initiated Job Accommodations for Workers with Serious Mental Illness
Baldwin ML, White RMB and Marcus SC
Many individuals with serious mental illness (SMI) are capable of employment in regular jobs (i.e. jobs paying at least minimum wage, not set aside for persons with disabilities, and not obtained with assistance from mental health services), but they may need job accommodations to be successful. The extant literature focuses almost exclusively on accommodations for workers with SMI who are receiving employment support, so we know almost nothing about the nature or frequency of accommodations needed by workers who are independently employed.
Perspectives on Financing Strategies for Evidence-Based Treatment Implementation in Youth Mental Health Systems
North MN, Dopp AR, Silovsky JF, Gilbert M and Ringel JS
Evidence-based treatments (EBTs) are critical to effectively address mental health problems among children and adolescents, but costly for mental health service agencies to implement and sustain. Financing strategies help agencies overcome cost-related barriers by obtaining financial resources to support EBT implementation and/or sustainment.
LETTER: The Effect of Mental Disorders on Caregiver Workforce Participation: The Hidden Societal Cost
Eckardt JP
No abstract.
Value-Based Insurance Design: Clinically Nuanced Consumer Cost-Sharing for Mental Health Services
Benson NM and Fendrick AM
While consumer cost-sharing is a widely used strategy to mitigate health care spending, numerous studies have demonstrated that even modest levels of out-of-pocket cost are associated with lower use of medical care, including clinically necessary, high-value services. Within mental health care, increases in cost-sharing are associated with reductions in use of mental health care and psychotropic medication use. Further, these reductions in mental health services and treatments can lead to downstream consequences including worsening of psychiatric illness and increased need for acute care and psychiatric hospitalization. Thus, there is a need for clinically informed solutions that explicitly balance the need for appropriate access to essential mental health services and treatments with growing fiscal pressures faced by public and private payers. Value-Based Insurance Design (VBID) describes a model where consumer cost-sharing is based on the potential clinical benefit rather than the price of a specific health care service or treatment.
PERSPECTIVE: Economic and Policy Research Interests Highlighted in the 25th NIMH-Sponsored Mental Health Services Research Conference
Humensky JL, Freed MC, Azrin ST, Acri M and Pintello D
The National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) remains committed to addressing real-world challenges with delivering high quality mental health care to people in need by advancing a services research agenda to improve access, continuity, quality, equity, and value of mental healthcare nationwide, and to improve outcomes for people with serious mental illnesses (SMI). The NIMH-Sponsored Mental Health Services Research Conference (MHSR) is a highly productive venue for discussing topics of interest to NIMH audiences and disseminating NIMH's latest research findings directly to mental health clinicians, policy makers, administrators, advocates, consumers, and scientists who attend.
Machine Learning with Human Resources Data: Predicting Turnover among Community Mental Health Center Employees
Fukui S, Wu W, Greenfield J, Salyers MP, Morse G, Garabrant J, Bass E, Kyere E and Dell N
Human resources (HR) departments collect extensive employee data that can be useful for predicting turnover. Yet, these data are not often used to address turnover due to the complex nature of recorded data forms.
PERSPECTIVE: Forecasting the Future: Lived Experience and the Transformation of Mental Health Services Research in the United States
Jones N, Mascayano F, Susser E and Yang LH
Over the past two decades, consensus has emerged in WHO and other international organizations regarding the foundational role and importance of integrated service users - individuals with lived experience of mental health services and systems - into mental health clinical and services research. At present, support and infrastructure in the United States (US) lags behind many other high-income, Anglophone and Western European countries. This Perspective, originally part of the 2022 NIMH Mental Health Services Research Conference's "Forecasting the Future" plenary panel, makes the case for systematic and coordinated investment in the policy, funding, infrastructure and organizational change that would be necessary to substantively strengthen participatory and co-produced mental health services research in the US.
Implementation of the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline: Estimating State-Level Increases in Call Demand Costs and Financing
Purtle J, Chance Ortego J, Bandara S, Goldstein A, Pantalone J and Goldman ML
Per federal law, "988" became the new three-digit dialing code for the National Suicide & Crisis Lifeline on July 16, 2022 (previously reached by dialing "1-800-283-TALK").
Workplace Disclosure of Serious Mental Illness and Gainful Employment: Theory and Evidence
Baldwin ML, DeSerpa AC and Marcus SC
This study provides the first systematic analysis of the association between workplace disclosure of serious mental illness (SMI) and the probability of gainful employment, among workers employed in regular jobs. By regular job, we mean one that pays at least minimum wage, is not set aside for persons with disabilities, and was not obtained with assistance of mental health services. By gainful employment, we mean a regular job with monthly earnings that exceed the maximum allowable earned income for receipt of Social Security Disability Insurance.
Changes in Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Use of Mental Health Services under the Affordable Care Act: Evidence from California
Kim LH, Hodgkin D, Larson MJ and Doonan M
The Affordable Care Act (ACA) aimed to expand mental health service use in the US, by expanding access to health insurance. However, the gap in mental health utilization by race and ethnicity is pronounced: members of racial and ethnic minoritized groups remain less likely to use mental health services than non-Hispanic White individuals even after the ACA.
Health Reporting from Different Data Sources: Does it Matter for Mental Health?
Mason J, Laporte A, McDonald JT, Kurdyak P and de Oliveira C
Mental disorders are typically stigmatized conditions associated with negative stereotypes, which may lead individuals to underreport them. Thus, survey data may be subject to biases. Although administrative data has some limitations, it is an alternative data source that may be considered more objective.
Economic Evaluation of Dialectical Behavioral Therapy Versus Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Suicide Prevention
Acolin J
Suicide is a leading cause of death for adults aged 18-64 in the United States, and suicide risk is highest among those with previous attempts. Two evidence-based treatments for suicide prevention exist: dialectical behavioral therapy (DBT), a year-long intensive treatment, and cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), a brief (10-12 session) treatment. To our knowledge, no direct comparison of the two treatments yet exists AIMS: To analyze the cost-effectiveness of DBT compared to CBT, in terms of both cost and quality of life, for the prevention of future suicide attempt among previous attempters.
Does Stimulus Check Payment Improve People's Mental Health in the COVID-19 Pandemic? Evidence from U.S. Household Pulse Survey
Chu L and Teng L
As the COVID-19 pandemic quickly spread worldwide, mental health deterioration was found to be closely associated with not only the contagious disease itself but also the financial struggles caused by job or income loss during this difficult time.
Psychometric Performance of the SF-6D Quality of Life Measure in an Outpatient Population with Bipolar Disorder
Pogue YZ, Lavelle TA, Hodgkin D, Sylvia L, Ritter G and Nierenberg A
Bipolar disorder is among the top 10 causes of disability worldwide. The Short-Form Six-Dimension (SF-6D) is a frequently used measure of preference-based health-related quality of life (HRQOL). However, this measure's psychometric performance has not been tested in outpatient patients with bipolar disorder.
The Effect of Being Unemployed on Mental Health: The Spanish Case
Escudero-Castillo I, Mato Diaz FJ and Rodriguez-Alvarez A
The lack of work appeared to be linked to several symptoms related to poor mental health. Likewise, the reverse relationship, namely the influence of poor mental health on the risk of job loss, has also been analysed, i.e. distress could lead to a poorer work performance culminating in potential job loss. Thus, the bidirectional nature of the relationship between unemployment and mental health makes the accurate estimation of causal relationships a complex matter, leaving room for additional research on the subject.
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of School-Based Treatments for Anxiety Disorders
Ginsburg GS, Pella JE and Slade E
School-based treatments for anxiety disorders are needed to address barriers to accessing community-based services. A key question for school administers are the costs related to these treatments.
Mental Health Problems and Risky Health Behaviors among Young Individuals in Turkey: The Case of Being NEET
Karaoglan D, Begen N and Tat P
The concept of neither in active employment nor in education and training (NEET) is quite important because it potentially addresses a broad array of vulnerabilities among the young, touching on issues of unemployment, early school leaving, and labor market discouragement.
Mask Mandate's Effect on Job Loss Expectation and Mental Health in the United States during the COVID-19 Pandemic
Mandal B
Uncertainty around economic recovery from a pandemic, in addition to restrictions on mobility and socializing, can be isolating and stressful. While preventive measures, such as mask mandates, are expected to mitigate spread of the disease and lower concerns of future job loss, state- and local-level mandates could signal that infection rates are worse in the mandated areas and decrease consumer confidence and mobility. Thus, the association between mask mandates and psychological well-being is unclear.