Exhaust flow calibration for a large-scale calorimetry system using tracer gas dilution
Exhaust flow measurements are a significant source of uncertainty for measurements of heat release rate in large-scale fire experiments. Irregular flow distributions are often present in the exhaust ducts making it difficult to measure flow accurately. Tracer gas dilution (TGD), a measurement method for volume flow, is not sensitive to flow distribution and has been applied to calibrate flow measurement devices at the exhaust ducts of a large-scale open calorimetry system. The in-line calibration reduced the bias in the exhaust flow measurement by as much as 6% improving the overall measurement accuracy of the heat release rate. Experimental results provide evidence that the flow calibration is an improvement over the accepted practice of developing a flow correction from the comparison of oxygen consumption calorimetry with the heat output from a gas burner. The flow calibration is valid for a wide range of flow conditions and decouples the oxygen consumption calorimetry measurement from any error in determining the heat release rate from the gas burner.
Performance and Failure Mechanism of Fire Barriers in Full-Scale Chair Mock-ups
The effectiveness and the failure mechanism of fire barriers in residential upholstered furniture were investigated by full-scale flaming tests on upholstered chair mock-ups. Six commercial fire barriers were tested in this study. Fire barriers were screened for (1) the presence of elements that are typically used in fire retardants and, (2) the presence of targeted fire retardants. For each fire barrier, triplicate flammability tests were run on chair mock-ups where polyurethane foam and polyester fiber fill were used as the padding materials, and each chair component was fully wrapped with the fire barrier of choice and a polypropylene cover fabric. The ignition source was an 18 kW square propane burner, impinging on the top surface of the seat cushion for 80 s. Results showed all six fire barriers reduced the peak heat release rate (as much as ≈ 64 %) and delayed its occurrence (up to ≈ 19 min) as compared to the control chair mock-ups. The heat release rate remained at a relatively low plateau level until liquid products (generated by either melting or pyrolysis of the padding material) percolated through the fire barrier at the bottom of the seat cushion and ignited, while the fire barrier was presumably intact. The flaming liquid products dripped and quickly formed a pool fire under the chair and the peak heat release rate occurred shortly thereafter. Ultimately, the ignition of the percolating liquid products at the bottom of the seat cushion was identified as the mechanism triggering the failure of the fire barrier.
Headspace sampling-gas chromatograph-mass spectrometer as a screening method to thermally extract fireground contaminants from retired firefighting turnout jackets
Firefighters are at a 1.5 to 2 times greater risk of contracting certain types of cancers as compared to the general population. After preliminary studies, it was evident that contaminated turnout gear and ensemble elements could be linked to heightened cancer rates amongst firefighters. Compounds such as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), perfluorinated compounds, phenols, phthalates, brominated flame retardants, dioxins, volatile organic compounds, and many others are present in the contaminated gear, of which many are known carcinogens. A setup of headspace sampler-gas chromatograph-mass spectrometer was used to measure the off-gassing of the fabric samples taken from retired field-contaminated turnout jackets. The fabric samples were exposed to a specific temperature and allowed to equilibrate for a fixed time in the HS. A custom reference mix of phenols, phthalates and PAHs was put together to develop standard calibration curves. The compounds off-gassing from the outer shell, thermal liner and the moisture barrier were analyzed and the masses of certain marker compounds were calculated based of the standard calibration curves. The technique could be used as a screening method to thermally extract contaminants from field-contaminated firefighter turnout materials such as jackets, pants, gloves, and so on.
Improved Calculation Method for Insulation-based Fire Resistance of Composite Slabs
Floor slabs play a critical role in the fire resistance of buildings, not only by maintaining structural stability and integrity, but also by providing thermal insulation to limit the rise in temperature of floors above a fire. Composite slabs, consisting of concrete topping on steel decking, are common in steel building construction, but the profiled geometry of the decking makes the analysis of heat transfer in composite slabs more complex than for flat slabs. A method for calculating the insulation-based fire resistance of composite slabs with profiled steel decking is provided in Annex D of Eurocode 4 (EC4). However, the applicability of the EC4 calculation method is limited to a range of commonly used slab geometries from the 1990s, which is narrower than the range used in current practice. In addition, the EC4 calculation method assumes a specific value of moisture content for the concrete, and different values of moisture content can significantly affect the fire resistance, as shown in this study. This paper proposes an improved algebraic expression for estimation of the insulation-based fire resistance of composite slabs that explicitly accounts for moisture content and is applicable to an extended range of slab geometries. The proposed expression is developed based on computed values of fire resistance obtained from a validated finite element modeling approach. A set of 54 composite slab configurations are selected for analysis using a sequential experimental design. The accuracy of the proposed method is verified against numerical results for an additional set of 32 slab configurations and is also validated against experimental data. Comparisons of the proposed calculation method with the results of the verification analyses show deviations of less than 15 min in all cases for the insulation-based fire resistance of the composite slabs.
The Performance of Wood and Tile Roofing Assemblies Exposed to Continuous Firebrand Assault
The performance of tile roofing assemblies as well as untreated cedar shake roofing assemblies exposed to continuous firebrand showers were compared. Specifically, experiments were conducted for two types of concrete tile roofing assemblies (flat and profiled), one type of terracotta tile roofing assembly (flat), and an untreated (without any fire retardant) cedar shake roofing assembly. The design of the roofing assemblies were based on construction guidelines in the USA. The duration of the firebrand flux was fixed at 20 minutes, and the wind speed was varied from 6 m/s to 9 m/s. These wind speeds were chosen to be able to compare roofing assembly performance to similar assemblies exposed to a batch-feed firebrand generator which had limited duration of firebrand exposure (6 min). The average firebrand mass flux that at the surface of the roofing assemblies was 0.3 g/ms Results indicated that for the untreated cedar shake assemblies, ignition occurred easily from the firebrand assault, and this type of roofing assembly generated their own firebrands after ignition. To attempt to quantify the degree of penetration, the number of firebrands that penetrated the tile roofing assemblies, and deposited onto the underlayment/counter-batten system was counted as function of wind speed for each assembly. Firebrand penetration was observed, even for the flat tile assemblies. It is believed that these are the first-ever experiments described in the peer-reviewed literature to expose wood and tile roofing experiments to continuous wind-driven firebrand showers.
Burning Down the Silos: Integrating new perspectives from the social sciences into human behavior in fire research
The traditional social science disciplines can provide many benefits to the field of human behavior in fire (HBiF). First, the social sciences delve further into insights only marginally examined by HBiF researchers, in turn, expanding the depth of HBiF research. In this paper, I present examples of studies from the fields of social psychology and sociology that would expand HBiF research into non-engineering or "unobservable" aspects of behavior during a fire event. Second, the social sciences can provide insight into new areas of research; in turn, expanding the scope of HBiF research. In this section, I introduce pre- and post-fire studies and explore potential research questions that fall outside of the response period of a fire, the phase upon which most focus is currently placed. Third, the social sciences elucidate the value of research methods available to study human behavior. Qualitative research methods are specifically highlighted. These three benefits will allow HBiF researchers to collect a wider range of data, further develop and expand current behavioral knowledge, and increase the impact of this research for both social and engineering applications. Finally, I end with a discussion on possible ways to better integrate the social sciences within human behavior in fire.
Quantifying Wind-Driven Firebrand Production from Roofing Assembly Combustion
Large outdoor fires present a risk to the built environment. Examples often in the international media reports are wildfires that spread into communities, referred to as Wildland-Urban Interface (WUI) fires. Other examples are large urban fires including those that have occurred after earthquakes. Firebrands are a key mechanism on how rapidly fires spread in urban fires and WUI fires. An experimental protocol has been developed to ignite full-scale roofing assemblies and quantify the degree of firebrand production during the combustion process. As wind is an important factor in firebrand generation, the experiments were conducted under a range of wind speeds at the Building Research Institute's (BRI) Fire Research Wind Tunnel Facility (FRWTF). A further unique aspect of this work is the experimental results are compared to firebrand size and mass distributions collected from an large-scale urban fire in Japan. Results of these experiments demonstrate that when only oriented strand board (OSB) is applied as sheathing, a significant number of firebrands collected from roofing assemblies were less than 1 g and 10 cm. It was also observed that experiments on individual building component firebrand generation provided useful insights into actual urban fire firebrand generation.
Fire resistance of cold-formed steel framed shear walls under various fire scenarios
This paper presents results of large-scale experiments with varying levels of fire severity on lateral force-resisting systems commonly used in cold-formed steel framed buildings. Gypsum-sheet steel composite panel sheathed walls, oriented strand board sheathed walls, and steel strap-braced walls are examined. Postflashover fire conditions of two different intensities as well as 1 hour of fire exposure similar to that in a standard furnace qualification test are studied. Additionally, a full-scale furnished kitchen fire experiment is conducted for comparison. The results highlight differences in the thermal response and subsequent performance of the walls as well as differing sensitives of the walls to pre-damage, eg, that might occur during an earthquake. The results are part of a larger effort to provide fragilities for these wall systems in response to realistic fires for performance-based design.
Application of Narrow-Spectrum Illumination and Image Processing to Measure Surface Char Formation in Lateral Ignition and Flame Spread Tests
The Lateral Ignition and Flame Spread Test (LIFT) is used to characterize fire ignition and flame spread on solid materials. This test requires the operator to visually monitor the flame spread over a combustible material and manually record the position of the flame during an experiment. Visual inspection limits the quantity of data obtained from a test and introduces uncertainty in the measurement. In this study, we use narrow-spectrum light with a peak wavelength of 450 nm and a digital camera with frequency-matched optical filters to capture images of surface charring, which underlies the flaming combustion, in a LIFT apparatus. The imaging technique reduced unwanted energy emissions from the flame in the visible light spectrum, allowing the test operator to directly view the charring of the material; which is otherwise hidden behind the flames. We describe data processing routines to analyze the sequences of high-resolution images. The method improves temporal and spatial resolution of the surface charring compared to visual observations.
Understanding Structure Ignition Vulnerabilities Using Mock-up Sections of Attached Wood Fencing Assemblies
Firebrand production from structure combustion becomes a key factor in the magnitude of how quickly a large outdoor fire may spread. Post-fire disaster investigations suggest that attached building components, such as wood fencing assemblies are known to be prone to ignition in these fires, and may provide pathways to structure ignition. Here, a comparison of ignition results from full-scale fencing assembly experiments conducted using a full-scale wind tunnel facility, to mock-ups of full-scale fencing assemblies using the recently developed experimental capability at the National Research Institute of Fire and Disaster (NRIFD) are discussed. In both experimental facilities, the fencing assemblies were exposed to firebrand showers using custom built continuous-feed firebrand generators with size and mass distributions similar to those generated from structure combustion. Similar ignition behaviors were observed between the full-scale fencing assemblies and the mock-up of full-scale fencing assemblies. Additional experiments are required for other fencing assembly types to further verify these important findings.
Toward understanding ignition vulnerabilities to firebrand showers using reduced-scale experiments
Over the past few years, the large outdoor fire problem has been a growing concern throughout the world. It is recommended to clear the combustibles around homes and within communities to avoid potential loss of properties, as firebrand shower ignition is a dangerous threat. One of the common combustibles around homes is mulching materials. A reduced-scale experimental protocol was developed to study ignition of mulching materials by firebrands and resulting impact to adjunct wall assemblies. Reduced-scale experimental results were compared with full-scale experimental results. Specifically, two trends were of interest in the comparisons. First, the ranking of the ease of ignition for various mulch types from exposure to firebrand showers. Second, if a given mulch type ignited from exposure to firebrand showers, was the resulting mulch bed fire able to ignite the adjacent wall assembly. The reduced-scale experimental results captured some of these trends observed from full-scale experiments but not completely. The findings still suggest that the reduced-scale experiments may give insights into how easily different mulch beds may be ignited by firebrands, as compared to much more costly and time-consuming full-scale experiments. While it is interesting to conduct full-scale experiments, this is very expensive and not always practical, so the authors are devising far cheaper reduced-scale experiments to provide more in-depth scientific understanding of firebrand shower ignition of construction components.
Estimating the impact of the mattress fire safety Standard 16 CFR Part 1633 on bed fire outcomes
Beds are a prevalent combustible in fatal fires in the United States effective 1 July 2007, the US Consumer Product Safety Commission promulgated a standard to severely reduce the heat release rate and the early heat output from mattresses and foundations when ignited by a flaming ignition source. This study estimates the Standard's success over its first decade using fire incidence, US population, and mattress sales data. The technique mitigates the influence of some exogenous factors that might have changed during this decade. The Standard is accomplishing its purpose, preventing approximately 65 fatalities (out of an estimated 95 fatalities in 2002-2005) from bed fires annually during 2015-2016, although not all pre-Standard mattresses had yet been replaced. Compared to residential upholstered furniture fires, which were not affected by the Standard, the numbers of bed fires decreased by 12%, injuries by 34%, and deaths by 82% between 2005-2006 and 2015-2016. Per bed fire, injuries decreased by 25% and fatalities decreased by 67%, indicating that the severity of bed fires is being reduced.